🔐 The OTP Crisis on RTI Portals: A Barrier to Transparency

The introduction of an OTP-based login system on Right to Information (RTI) portals, while intended to boost security and user authentication, has ironically become a major roadblock, severely disrupting citizens’ ability to exercise their fundamental right to information.
This issue is particularly pronounced in Haryana, where applicants report systemic failures in receiving the necessary One-Time Passwords, leading to frustration and confusion.
Many citizens, who rely on this mechanism to access crucial information regarding government actions and decisions, find themselves in a state of helplessness, as repeated attempts to log in often result in failed authentication.
Furthermore, the lack of clear communication from authorities regarding the technical glitches exacerbates the problem, leaving individuals uncertain about when or if the issues will be resolved.
As a result, the implementation of this security measure, which was meant to enhance privacy, has instead become a significant barrier to transparency and accountability, undermining the very purpose of the RTI framework.

---

🛑 Impact and Technical Glitches

The primary consequence of this technical failure is that citizens are locked out of the digital RTI system, which significantly hampers their ability to access vital information that is crucial for transparency and accountability within governmental processes.
This lack of access not only frustrates the public but also undermines trust in the system, leaving many feeling disenfranchised and disconnected from the decision-making processes that affect their lives.
Furthermore, the inability to utilize the digital platform exacerbates existing inequalities, as those who rely heavily on timely information for advocacy or legal recourse are disproportionately affected.
Ultimately, this technical glitch poses a serious barrier to participatory democracy and hampers efforts to promote good governance.

• Denied Access: Many applicants are unable to receive the OTP via email or mobile, which prevents them from submitting new applications or checking the status of existing ones.
• Frustration and Delay: This glitch has caused significant user frustration, leading to delays in the process and undermining the core purpose of the RTI Act, 2005—to ensure timely transparency and accountability.
• Sporadic Performance: Users report issues like sporadic OTP delivery, long wait times, and portal stalls, especially when attempting to view official replies.

The experience of Mahesh Pratap Singh, who struggled to register his application due to the non-receipt of the OTP on his mobile number, is a clear example of this systemic failure.

---

🏛️ Public Grievance vs. Official Stance

The response to the OTP issue highlights a disparity between user experience and official claims.

• Public Action: Public-spirited individuals and RTI activists have escalated the matter, making a formal representation to the Chief Information Commissioner (CIC) of Haryana and urging immediate remedial action.
• Government Claim: The Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) has publicly stated that the OTP feature is “functioning smoothly,” citing a high number of successful accesses.
• The Reality Gap: This official claim contradicts the continued reports from users who are experiencing significant technical barriers. As one applicant stated, such technical failures can be seen as “wicked techniques” that deprive information seekers.

---

💡 Broader Implications: Why This Matters

The technical barrier created by the OTP failure has grave implications for democracy and governance:

• Negating Digital Purpose: Delays or failures in OTP delivery negate the convenience and efficiency that digital RTI services were supposed to provide.
• Stalling Accountability: Crucial issues related to corruption, public welfare, and governance remain unaddressed because citizens are prevented from seeking information due to a technical glitch.
• The Second Appeal Digitalisation Issue: The same communication highlights a related issue: the slow progress in the digitalisation of the second appeal process in the State Information Commission (SIC), even after a Supreme Court order to ensure compliance by the end of 2023. This points to a broader pattern of resistance or delay in adopting digital transparency measures.

---

📢 Recommended Action Plan

To overcome this digital roadblock and push for greater accountability, citizens and activists can take several proactive steps:

1. File a Public Grievance: Lodge a complaint on the Public Grievance Portal, specifically citing the OTP failure and attaching screenshots or other evidence.
2. Formal Complaint to SIC: Send a direct, formal complaint to the State Information Commission, Haryana, detailing the inability to file or check applications due to the portal issue.
3. Request Manual Submission: If the portal remains inaccessible, formally request a manual RTI submission option to ensure the legal right to information is not denied.
4. Escalate to DoPT: Directly contact the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) via email or social media, referencing the OTP failure and its negative impact on the implementation of the RTI Act.

“बर्बाद गुलिस्ताँ करने को बस एक ही उल्लू काफ़ी था/ हर शाख़ पे उल्लू बैठा है अंजाम-ए-गुलिस्ताँ क्या होगा”

This couplet aptly captures the sentiment: while a single issue can cause disruption and create ripples of concern among the public, a multitude of governance failures, including technical neglect, can devastate the promise of transparency and accountability, eroding trust in institutions that are supposed to serve the people.
When various interconnected problems arise, they can compound each other, leading not only to chaos but also to an overwhelming sense of disillusionment among citizens who expect their leaders to uphold ethical standards and ensure the smooth functioning of systems designed to protect their rights and welfare.
Ultimately, it is this culmination of failures that poses a significant threat, as the dark clouds of uncertainty loom larger, hindering progress and stifling the very ideals that a robust society is built upon.

---

Would you like me to draft a template for a formal complaint to the State Information Commission regarding the OTP issue?