Administrative Failure or Digital Deception? The 5-Year Struggle for Land Records in Mirzapur

The promise of a “Digital India” relies on the integrity of its data. Cases of Digital Deception are becoming more evident. A recent case from Sadar Tehsil, District Mirzapur, shows a troubling gap. It highlights the difference between what the government shows the public online and what exists in their internal databases. This discrepancy has led to years of unnecessary harassment for citizens seeking their rightful inheritance.

---

The Core Issue: A 1,600-Day “Invisible” Record (Digital Deception)

The matter involves the inheritance (Virasaat) of land following the death of Rajendra Pratap Singh. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate (SDM) issued a formal mutation order on October 18, 2021. Despite this, the legal heirs found themselves in a bizarre administrative limbo.

The names of the heirs were visible on the public UP Bhulekh portal. They included—Vidya Devi, Mahesh Pratap Singh, Arun Pratap Singh, and Keshav Pratap Singh. However, the internal “Main Khata” at the Tehsil level remained unupdated. For over three years, due to this data mismatch, the tehsil staff manipulated for deceptive practices and harassment.

The Ground Reality: Misinformation and Red Tape

In December 2025, during a village camp in Neebigharwar, Tehsil staff informed the family about a case of Digital Deception. They said that their names were “not in the computer.” They were told to contact the Lekhpal personally. The record should have been synchronised automatically years ago.

This situation raises critical questions:

• How can a record be “public” on a government website but “missing” in the office that uploaded it?
• Is this a technical failure, or a deliberate attempt to force citizens into “unofficial negotiations” with revenue officials?

The Investigation: A Belated Admission (Digital Deception)

Following a formal grievance (GOVUP/E/2025/0132441), an investigation report dated December 10, 2025, confirmed the heirs’ claims. The Revenue Inspector acknowledged that the names were missing from the “Main Khata.” He assured that they have now been updated.

However, the “Case Closed” status provided by the authorities is a superficial victory. It fixes the record but ignores the accountability for the three-year delay.

Demanding Accountability: Moving Beyond “Case Closed”

The complainant, Yogi M. P. Singh, has rightly rejected the closure of the grievance, citing “Harassment by Officials.” The demand is clear:

1. Inquiry into the Delay: A formal investigation was conducted. It aimed to discover the reasons for the delay. The judicial order from 2021 took until late 2025 to reflect in the internal server.
2. Identification of Responsibility: Accountability must be fixed on the computer operators and revenue staff who oversaw this 1,000-day lapse. (Digital Deception)
3. Systemic Reform: We need to ensure that the “public view” and “internal view” of land records are identical. This will prevent staff from using data gaps to harass the public.

---

Conclusion(Digital Deception)

Digital records empower citizens; however, they do not shield against administrative negligence. This case starkly reminds us that “Case Closed” does not always mean “Justice Served.” Moreover, the officials responsible for this three-year delay must be held accountable. Until then, we consequently question the Revenue Department’s transparency.

2021 to 2026: A Five-Year Timeline of Administrative Apathy (Digital Deception)

When a family loses a patriarch, the state must ensure a seamless legal transition. The case of Rajendra Pratap Singh is noteworthy. He passed away in 2021. The Revenue Department of Sadar Tehsil, Mirzapur, failed to progress digitally. The expected digital transition did not happen; instead, it became defined by “Digital Ghosting.”

1. The Judicial Success vs. The Ground Failure (Digital Deception)

In October 2021, the authorities passed a mutation order, winning the legal battle. For the next four years, the Tehsil’s internal records did not reflect the order’s reality. This created a “Ghost Record.” This record was made publicly available on the UP Bhulekh portal. However, it went “missing” when a citizen stood before a desk at the Tehsil office.

2. The Trap of “Personal Contact”

The most alarming aspect of this case is, indeed, the advice that the heirs received in 2025. Specifically, they remarked, “The names are not in the computer; therefore, contact the Lekhpal personally.”

• The Reality: The data was already on the central server (Bhulekh).
• The Implication: This suggests that, consequently, authorities deliberately create a “bottleneck”. They withhold internal synchronisation in order to, ultimately, force citizens to engage in face-to-face interactions, which often, as a result, become breeding grounds for petty corruption.

3. The “Midnight” Correction of December 2025

The records magically “appeared” in the Main Khata on December 10, 2025. This happened after someone escalated a formal grievance to the Chief Minister’s Secretariat. While officials corrected the record, the 2021-2025 gap still remains a black hole of accountability.

4. Why “Case Closed” is Not Enough (Digital Deception)

The Joint Secretary’s office closed the grievance based on a report that simply states, “the work is done.” This resolution is unacceptable because:

1. It ignores the delay: There is no explanation for the 1,500-day lag.
2. It protects the negligent: the computer operators did not synchronise the data for 4 years. The revenue officials also failed in this task. Both groups face no consequences.
3. It ignores the harassment: Moreover, the family endures years of uncertainty. Consequently, they confront the threat of exclusion from the Farmer Registry (PM-Kisan).

---

The Path Forward for 2026: Fixing Accountability

As we enter 2026, we must shift our objective from correction to consequence. A digital system remains only as honest as the people who operate it. If a judicial order from 2021 can be ignored until 2025, then we clearly have a fundamentally broken system.

The Demand:

The District Magistrate of Mirzapur must, therefore, initiate a Technical Audit of the Sadar Tehsil’s mutation entry logs for 2021. We need to identify who held the file and, furthermore, understand the reasons behind the blocked synchronisation. Additionally, we require clarification on why the public portal and internal server have been, consequently, at odds for four years.

---

Suggested Next Step

Would you like me to draft a specific RTI (Right to Information) application? First, we can request the Tehsil to provide the names of the officials who were responsible for data entry between 2021 and 2025. Consequently, this is often the most effective way to “name and shame” the individuals responsible for the delay.

Summary of the Investigation Report (Janch Akhya)

The handwritten report dated 10-12-2025 (Document conv 0.jpeg) signed by the Revenue Inspector and Lekhpal (Pawan Kumar Shukla) states the following:

• Verification of Heirs: The investigation confirms that Rajendra Pratap Singh has passed away. Consequently, authorities issued an order to record his heirs: Vidya Devi, Mahesh Pratap Singh, Arun Pratap Singh, and Keshav Pratap Singh.
• Correction Made: The report explicitly states the names of the heirs for Gata numbers 173, 174, and 217. It also includes numbers 5563, 569, and 570. Additionally, it lists numbers 571, 603, and 135. We have now recorded these names in the Main Khata (Main Account) of the computer records.
• Resolution: The Lekhpal reports that the names are now visible, and the applicant can proceed with further registrations (e.g., PM-Kisan/Farmer Registry).

Status of the Khatauni (Land Record)

The uploaded Khatauni (Document conv 1.jpeg and conv 2.jpeg) confirms the synchronisation:

• Khata Number: 00376
• Gata Number: 173 (Unique Code: 2111260173000012)
• Recorded Names: The records list all four heirs (Arun, Keshav, Mahesh, and Vidya Devi) under Column 2.
• Area Share: The total area of 0.0760 hectares, divided equally among the four heirs, with each heir receiving 0.0190 hectares.

---

Analysis of the Grievance Disposal

The grievance (GOVUP/E/2025/0132441) was marked as “Case Closed” on 11/12/2025.

The Good News:

The primary administrative hurdle presents a discrepancy between the UP Bhulekh portal and the Tehsil’s internal “Main Khata” display. However, this issue appears to be resolved. Furthermore, the Lekhpal’s report confirms that the technical synchronisation error is fixed.

The Unresolved Issues:

Despite the closure, the “Action Sought” in your original grievance was only partially addressed:

1. Verification: Complete. The records now match. (Digital Deception)
2. Formal Explanation: Joint Secretary Arvind Mohan provides generic “Remarks” (“Report is attached for perusal”). He does not explain why it took 5 years or why the staff previously gave misinformation.
3. Accountability: The report focuses on the fix but ignores the “procedural failure” and “corruption/harassment” aspect you highlighted.

To help you pursue accountability, here are the essential contact details. Additionally, we provide web links for the relevant authorities in Mirzapur and Lucknow to help you maintain your records.

1. District Administration (Mirzapur)

Designation	Mobile / CUG	Email Address
District Magistrate (DM)	9454417567	dmmir@nic.in
Additional District Magistrate	9454417640	–
Sub-Divisional Magistrate (SDM) Sadar	9454417728	–
Tehsildar Sadar	9454416848	–

• Address: Collectorate Compound, Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh – 231001.

---

2. State Revenue Board & Technical Helpdesk (Lucknow)

For issues regarding data synchronisation between the internal server and the public portal.

Department	Phone / Helpline	Email Address
Board of Revenue (General)	0522-2217155	borlko@nic.in
UP Bhulekh Helpline	0522-2217145	bhulekh-up@gov.in
Technical Support (Official)	7080100588	helpdesk.upbhulekh@nic.in
RCCMS (Revenue Courts)	0522-2217145	rccms-up@gov.in

• Address: Computer Cell, Revenue Council, Kesarbagh, Lucknow – 226001.

---

3. Essential Web Links (Digital Deception)

• Official Land Records Portal: upbhulekh.gov.in (To verify real-time Khatauni)
• Grievance Redressal Portal (IGRS): jansunwai.up.nic.in (To file your appeal or track status)
• Revenue Court Management: vaad.up.nic.in (To track mutation case histories)
• Mirzapur District Website: mirzapur. nic.in

---

4. Direct Accountability Contacts (Secretariat) (Digital Deception)

The Joint Secretary closed your grievance. You can contact his office directly for clarification on the “Generic Remarks.”

• Officer: Shri Arvind Mohan (Joint Secretary)
• Phone: 0522-2226350
• Email: arvind.12574@gov.in
• Address: Chief Minister Secretariat, Room No. 321, U.P. Secretariat, Lucknow.