Introduction

Matter of cyber-criminal activities are closed arbitrarily by government staff, often with little regard for the complexities involved in digital crime. This haphazard approach is resulting in the 0% success rate in the cases of cyber crimes, a disheartening statistic that reflects systemic failures.
Currently, the fourth investigation officer is investigating the case, yet his efforts seem to yield minimal results as no concrete evidence has been collected by him thus far.
The lack of adequate training and resources for investigative personnel further exacerbates the problem, leaving victims without justice and emboldening cyber criminals to exploit vulnerabilities without fear of repercussions.
This cycle of inaction not only undermines public trust in law enforcement but also highlights a pressing need for reforms that prioritize thorough investigations and the utilization of advanced technology in combating cyber crime.

Citizen’s Plea in Cyber Case After Key Officer’s Transfer

Mr. Yogi M. P. Singh filed a representation with the Superintendent of Police (SP), Cyber Crime, in Lucknow, highlighting urgent concerns about a pending financial cyber case that has left many individuals vulnerable and questioning their safety in the digital landscape.
Dated December 15, 2024, the plea follows a specific order from the Uttar Pradesh Information Commission (UPSIC), which mandates swift action on such critical matters.
It raises significant questions about potential delays and the efficiency of ongoing investigations, especially in light of the recent transfer of the investigating officer just before a crucial hearing involving the cyber fraud case.
This transfer has not only caused concern about continuity and expertise in handling the case but has also led to fears that the affected victims may never see justice served.
The impact of cybercrime on individuals can be devastating, and the urgency cannot be overstated, as it directly affects the trust in the system designed to protect the public.

---

UPSIC Orders Action and Progress Report

The Uttar Pradesh Information Commission heard the case on November 25, 2024, before the Hon’ble State Chief Information Commissioner, Dr. Rajkumar Vishwakarma, who presided over the session with great attention to detail and a commitment to ensuring that all voices were heard.
The case addressed critical concerns regarding government negligence in deforestation, drawing attention to the environmental impact and the urgent need for sustainable practices.
Multiple stakeholders participated in the proceedings, presenting evidence and arguments that underscored the importance of preserving natural resources.
Dr. Vishwakarma emphasised the role of transparency and accountability in governmental functions, reiterating that it is imperative for citizens to be actively involved in advocating for ecological conservation and responsible governance.

The Commission acknowledged the matter as a serious case of financial fraud in its order; consequently, it instructed the Superintendent of Police, Cyber Crime, Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow, to take suo motu cognizance of the case. Furthermore, it also instructed him to ensure that appropriate action is taken for its disposal in the context of this major cyber fraud case.

The Commission ordered Shri Arvind Kumar Yadav, Inspector, Police Station Katra, District Mirzapur to submit a report on the action taken; furthermore, a progress report at the next hearing was also required.

• Next Hearing Date: December 19, 2024

---

A New Hurdle: Investigating Officer Transferred

Mr. Singh, the applicant, highlights a significant development; moreover, the authorities have transferred Inspector Arvind Kumar Yadav from Kotwali Katra to Kotwali Dehat, complicating the cyber fraud case proceedings.
This transfer not only disrupts the investigation’s continuity but also raises concerns about the level of expertise that will now oversee the ongoing case.
With the new inspector potentially lacking the specific knowledge and contextual understanding that Inspector Yadav had cultivated during the initial stages of the investigation, there is a palpable fear among the stakeholders involved.
Consequently, this raises a critical question about compliance with the Commission’s order and whether the change in personnel might lead to delays or mismanagement of crucial evidence, further complicating an already intricate case.

Mr. Singh expresses concern that, consequently, authorities may use this transfer as a “new pretext” for delaying the investigation. Furthermore, he questions how Inspector Yadav, who is no longer the investigating officer in the case, can, in fact, submit the required progress report. This, as stated, is explicitly named in the Commission’s directive.

---

An Urgent Appeal for Accountability in a cyber case

The representation directly appeals to the SP Cyber Crime to ensure that the UPSIC, a constitutional body, follows “in letter and spirit,” thus upholding the essential legal frameworks that govern its operations.
Moreover, Mr. Singh urges the SP to diligently prepare the necessary reports for the upcoming hearing on December 19, 2024, emphasising the importance of generating comprehensive documentation to substantiate the claims at hand.
This measure is crucial for the cyber fraud case, as it aims to bring all pertinent evidence to light and prevent the legal proceedings from stalling or being adversely impacted by any oversight.
By ensuring thorough preparation and adherence to legal standards, the involved parties can work towards justice in what has become a complex and pressing issue within the realm of cybercrime.

He pleads, therefore, to ensure that bureaucratic changes do not impede the investigation’s progress. Additionally, it is essential to uphold the spirit of the Commission’s order for a swift resolution of the cyber fraud case.

---

Case Details and Applicant Information

• Appeal Number: S-01/0061/A/2024
• Applicant: Yogi M. P. Singh
• Contact:
  • Email: yogimpsingh@gmail.com
  • Mobile: 7379105911

Our chief minister claims to control crime even when cyber-crimes at its zenith