The following are the key takeaways from the administrative and legal challenge regarding the PM-Kisan scheme in Mirzapur. There have been several PM-Kisan Obstructions in Mirzapur, which have impacted the implementation of the scheme in the region:
1. The Documentation Discrepancy
- Official Recognition: The PM-Kisan beneficiary list for Village Nibi Gaharwar (March 2025) is noteworthy. It explicitly lists Keshav Pratap Singh at Serial Number 244.
- Contradictory Status: Despite this listing, the Deputy Director of Agriculture (DDA) claims the application was “Rejected” at the Tehsil level.
- Pending Evidence: Farmer status screenshots contradict the DDA’s claim, showing the application is actually “Pending for approval at Sub-District/Block Level”.
2. Digital vs. Manual Governance
- Land Verification: Digital Bhulekh records from November 2024 confirm the landholding of the beneficiary’s father. His name is Rajendra Pratap Singh. The landholding is for Gata Number 1351.
- Legal Standing: Under the Information Technology Act, 2000, these digital records hold the same legal weight as certified physical copies.
- Redundant Demands: Authorities continue to demand physical Khatauni and bank passbooks. They ignore the Aadhaar Payment Bridge System (APBS) guidelines where Aadhaar acts as the financial address.
3. RTI Procedural Failures
- “Recycled” Appeals: The First Appellate Authority (FAA) failed to provide a “Reasoned Order.” Instead, they simply re-attached the PIO’s original, flawed responses.
- Identification Omissions: Official correspondence (Letters 5813 and 5215) omitted specific RTI IDs and Appeal Numbers, hindering accountability.
- Misuse of Exemptions: The PIO invoked Section 8(1)(j) (Personal Information). They aimed to hide the names of officials responsible for a 10-month processing delay.
4. Technical and Systemic Barriers
- Email Failures: Technical logs revealed “4.4.1 timeout errors” for the Directorate’s official email (dirag@up.nic.in), obstructing digital communication.
- Grievance Disconnect: The local district office claimed “no knowledge” of a Central Government Grievance (Ref: DOAAC/E/2025/0045542). This shows a lack of synchronization between central and local systems.
5. Legal Escalation
- Second Appeal: A Second Appeal (A-20260400311) has been registered with the Uttar Pradesh Information Commission.
- Relief Sought: The appeal demands the synchronization of local portals with digital Bhulekh records. It also requires the imposition of penalties on the PIO under Section 20(1) for providing misleading information.
PM-Kisan Obstructions in Mirzapur: Administrative Anarchy and the Digital Divide
The Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi (PM-Kisan) scheme aims to support farmers through Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT). This system should remove middlemen by using technology. However, district-level execution in Mirzapur often ignores central mandates. The case of Keshav Pratap Singh shows how bureaucratic protocols block legitimate beneficiaries. Furthermore, the situation in Mirzapur reveals ongoing PM-Kisan obstructions that result from administrative apathy and digital access gaps.
1. The Beneficiary List Paradox
A major contradiction exists within official records. The PM-Kisan list for Village Nibi Gaharwar recognises Keshav Pratap Singh as a beneficiary at Serial Number 244>. Despite this, the Deputy Director of Agriculture (DDA) claims the application is “Rejected” at the Tehsil level. This creates a loop where a farmer appears eligible to the public but remains blocked internally, a clear illustration of how PM-Kisan Obstructions in Mirzapur can be both visible and concealed in the system.
2. Digital Records vs. Manual Demands
Modern rules prioritise Aadhaar-based e-KYC and digital land records (Bhulekh). The November 19, 2025 Central Mandate reinforces this digital transparency. This conflict between digital mandates and outdated manual processes is common in PM-Kisan obstructions found within Mirzapur.
- Bhulekh Evidence: Digital records from November 2, 2024, confirm Rajendra Pratap Singh as the landholder for Gata Number 1351.
- Legal Standing: The Information Technology Act, 2000, gives digital records the same legal weight as certified copies.
- The Conflict: The DDA continues to demand physical “certified Khatauni” and bank passbooks. These demands ignore the Aadhaar Payment Bridge System (APBS).
3. Procedural Failures in the RTI Process
The Right to Information (RTI) Act should ensure accountability. Instead, the appellant reports “procedural forgery”. In fact, Mirzapur’s persistent PM-Kisan Obstructions highlight flaws in transparency at every level.
- Recycled Replies: The First Appellate Authority (FAA) disposed of appeal DRAGR/A/2025/60170 by re-attaching the PIO’s original documents.
- Lack of Reasoned Orders: The FAA failed to address specific appeal grounds.
- Strategic Omissions: Official letters often omit RTI IDs and Appeal Numbers. This prevents tracking specific queries.
4. Misusing Privacy Laws (PM-Kisan Obstructions in Mirzapur)
In a later RTI, the DDA used Section 8(1)(j) to hide information. They refused to provide progress reports or the names of negligent officials. The department called this “personal information”. However, the duties and identities of public servants are matters of public record. This tactic shields staff who keep applications “Pending” for months. Such use of privacy provisions is among the unique PM-Kisan Obstructions emerging in Mirzapur’s administration.
5. Technical Barriers and Silent Grievances
The Directorate’s digital systems also fail citizens. Evidence shows the official email dirag@up.nic.in suffered “4.4.1 timeout errors” in early 2026. This blocks formal communication. Additionally, the district office denied knowledge of Central Grievance DOAAC/E/2025/0045542. This suggests a disconnect between central portals and local execution cells, reflecting recurring PM-Kisan Obstructions encountered in everyday Mirzapur complaints.
6. The Appeal to the Information Commission
The appellant has now filed a Second Appeal (A-20260400311) with the State Information Commission. This appeal demands:
- System Synchronisation: The PIO must align the local portal with digital Bhulekh records to approve the application. In addition, the appeal addresses PM-Kisan Obstructions faced specifically within Mirzapur’s official pipeline.
- Accountability: The Commission should penalise the PIO under Section 20(1) for providing misleading information.
- Transparency: The department must name the officials responsible for the 10-month processing delay.
Conclusion
The case of Keshav Pratap Singh highlights a systemic struggle. For PM-Kisan to work, district authorities must follow APBS guidelines. They must also respect the legal status of digital records. Until local staff stop manual interference, the digital divide will continue to block legitimate state benefits. Clearly, Mirzapur’s unique patterns of PM-Kisan Obstructions require urgent systemic change to ensure fair delivery.
Based on the provided documents and RTI records, here are the specific application IDs, contact details, and web links for the concerned public authorities:
1. RTI & Appeal Registration Numbers (PM-Kisan Obstructions in Mirzapur)
- Initial RTI Request: DRAGR/R/2025/60325 (Filed: 02/12/2025).
- First Appeal: DRAGR/A/2025/60170 (Filed: 26/12/2025).
- Second Appeal (UPSIC): A-20260400311 (Filed: 03/04/2026).
- Directorate Clarification RTI: DRAGR/R/2026/60076 (Filed: 10/02/2026).
- Secondary RTI (Delay/Officials): DRAGR/R/2025/60357.
- Central Government Grievance: DOAAC/E/2025/0045542.
2. Public Authority Contact Details (PM-Kisan Obstructions in Mirzapur)
| Authority | Name/Designation | Mobile Number | Email Address |
| PIO (District) | Vikesh Kumar, Deputy Director Agriculture (DDA), Mirzapur | 7839882478 | ddamzp2012@gmail.com |
| FAA (Division) | Joint Director Agriculture (JDA), Vindhyachal Mandal | 7668571373 | jdavindhyachal@gmail.com |
| Nodal Officer (HQ) | Additional Director Agriculture, Uttar Pradesh | 8081560096 | dirag@up.nic.in |
3. Official Web Links (PM-Kisan Obstructions in Mirzapur)
- PM-Kisan Beneficiary Status: https://pmkisan.gov.in/rpt_beneficiarystatus_pub.aspx.
- UP Bhulekh (Land Records): https://upbhulekh.gov.in (referenced via portal records).
- UP RTI Online Portal: https://rtionline.up.gov.in (referenced via registration data).
- UP Information Commission (UPSIC): https://upsic.up.gov.in (referenced via second appeal registration).
4. Farmer Registration IDs (Mentioned in Delay Complaint) (PM-Kisan Obstructions in Mirzapur)
The following IDs were cited as being held in “Pending” status for over 10 months:
- 20250119514266
- 20250119512524
- 20250119193467
Facing a similar challenge? Share the details in the box below, and our team of experts will do their best to help.