The PM Kisan Samman Nidhi scheme has encountered significant issues, with arbitrary rejection of applications and procrastination becoming a troubling trend that undermines its intended purpose.
Despite the government’s efforts to support farmers, the implementation has been marred by rampant corruption, which has prevented the funds from reaching the needy farmers as effectively as the PM Kisan Samman Nidhi was designed to do.
As a result, many farmers find themselves in precarious financial situations, struggling to make ends meet while waiting for assistance that never arrives.
This inefficiency not only erodes trust in the scheme but also exacerbates the economic challenges faced by the rural farming community, highlighting the urgent need for reforms to ensure the program truly benefits those it was meant to serve.

Urgent Attention Required: Alleged Corruption and Delays in PM Kisan Samman Nidhi Scheme

The noble objective of the Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi (PM-KISAN) scheme is to provide income support to all landholding farmer families, aiming to enhance their financial stability and improve their quality of life. However, this well-intentioned objective appears to be hampered by what is alleged to be arbitrary rejections, which leave many deserving families in a state of uncertainty and distress. There are also claims of application procrastination, where the processing of applications is unnecessarily delayed, combined with rampant corruption that undermines the integrity of the system. This troubling situation is reportedly preventing the intended financial aid from reaching the genuinely needy farmers, who rely on this support to sustain their livelihoods and invest in their agricultural activities, ultimately jeopardizing their future and that of the agricultural sector as a whole.

The following details, derived from an RTI application, highlight specific grievances related to the scheme’s implementation in Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh, and how these impact the outcomes of the PM Kisan Samman Nidhi programme.

---

Case Study: RTI Highlighting Grievances in Mirzapur

Yogi M P Singh has filed a Right to Information (RTI) application. The application is about the status of a specific beneficiary. It also concerns the process followed by the local agriculture department officials handling PM Kisan Samman Nidhi distribution.

Detail	Information
RTI Registration Number	DRAGR/R/2025/60044
Date of Filing	11/03/2025
Public Authority	Agriculture Directorate
Concerned PIO	Deputy Director Agriculture (DDA), Mirzapur
Beneficiary Concern	Keshav Pratap Singh, S/O: Rajendra Pratap Singh (Serial No. 244 in beneficiary list)

Specific Allegations and Information Sought:

The applicant is seeking clear, point-wise responses from the Deputy Director of Agriculture, Mirzapur, concerning the following issues:

1. Exclusion of Father’s Name: The father’s name is not included in the beneficiary list. This exclusion occurs despite the applicant’s name being present on the PM Kisan Samman Nidhi beneficiary list.
2. Demand for Documents: The Deputy Director of Agriculture (DDA) has requested copies of Khatauni (land record). They also require the applicant’s Aadhaar card and passbook.
3. Basis of Document Demand: The relevant Government Order, circular, or office memo authorizes the DDA to demand these documents. Please provide a copy of such gazette.
4. District-Level Intervention: Why do officials demand documents after the online application receives approval at the Sub-District or Block level? Why do they request sending them from the district level to the block level?
5. Withholding of Installments: The authorities are not sending the PM-KISAN installments to the beneficiary’s bank account. This affects Keshav Pratap Singh. His name is included in the official beneficiary list at serial number 244.
6. Seeking Bank Details: Please clarify and provide the circular that specifies why we seek bank details. We often make payments through the India Post Payments Bank via Aadhaar seeding.

---

The Concern: An Accountability Crisis

This detailed RTI application points towards a significant bureaucratic bottleneck and potential misuse of power at the local level:

• Information Asymmetry: Demanding documents that should have already been verified during the initial online application process. It shows distrust in the established system. This demand may also indicate a new, unpublished procedural hurdle in PM Kisan Samman Nidhi.
• Procedural Opacity: There is a request for the specific government circular backing the demand for documents (Khatauni, Aadhaar, Passbook). This highlights a concern that the process might be arbitrary. It may not be based on clear, mandated guidelines.
• Failure of Delivery: The core issue remains the non-disbursement of funds to a farmer. His name is already on the official beneficiary list. This situation defeats the very purpose of the scheme.
• Aadhaar-Based Payment Bypass: Questioning the demand for bank account details raises suspicion. This is especially true when Aadhaar-based payments via India Post Payments Bank is a prevalent method. The intent behind the request becomes questionable.

This case exemplifies the larger trend of administrative roadblocks. Alleged corruption often prevents crucial welfare schemes like PM-KISAN from achieving their intended impact on the ground. Immediate action is essential from the concerned authorities. Transparent responses are needed to restore faith in the system. These measures ensure the benefits reach the rightful farmers under the PM Kisan Samman Nidhi initiative.

🎯 Conclusion: Reforming PM-KISAN for Accountability and Impact

The extensive evidence, particularly the detailed RTI application from Mirzapur, highlights a troubling gap between the noble intent of the PM-KISAN scheme and its on-ground execution. The prevailing atmosphere of procedural opacity, arbitrary rejections, and alleged corruption is actively preventing the intended financial relief from reaching the rightful beneficiaries. This situation is more than a bureaucratic inconvenience; it represents a crisis of accountability that directly impacts the financial stability of the nation’s farmers.

To restore faith and ensure the scheme achieves its mandated goal of supporting vulnerable farmer families, immediate and decisive action is required:

• Mandatory Transparency: All document demands and application rejections must be backed by a publicly available, dated, and cited Government Order or circular.
• Streamlined Verification: The practice of demanding already-verified documents at the district level must cease. The initial online approval process should be treated as the final administrative gateway.
• Zero Tolerance for Corruption: A dedicated, fast-track grievance redressal mechanism is essential to investigate and penalize officials and intermediaries found engaging in corrupt practices or unnecessary delays.

The success of the PM-KISAN initiative is paramount to agricultural welfare. It is time for the concerned authorities to provide transparent responses and implement robust systemic reforms. Only through unwavering commitment to efficiency, integrity, and farmer-centric delivery can this crucial public aid program truly serve those it was designed to empower. The farmers cannot afford to wait; the time for decisive administrative action is now.

Public aids to farmers under P.M. Kisan Samman nidhi are not reaching to needy

PM Kisan Samman Nidhi is not reaching to entitled people because it has been hub of brokers and intermediaries who are stumbling block