DDO Mirzapur withheld information about transfer and posting details in the city block Mirzapur, causing considerable concern among local employees who rely on this information for their career planning and decision-making.
The lack of transparency has led to confusion and speculation about the criteria for transfers, creating an environment of uncertainty that affects morale.
Many individuals are left wondering about their job security and potential career advancement opportunities, as the absence of these crucial details hampers their ability to prepare for future roles within the organization.
🚨 RTI Second Appeal Filed Against DDO Mirzapur for Withholding Information
Despite the RTI application being received, no response was provided by the Public Information Officer (PIO), Mr. Shravan Kumar Rai, who oversees various issues such as those related to DDO Mirzapur.
This lack of response raises significant concerns regarding transparency and accountability within the office. It reflects a troubling trend where they have made a conscious decision not to entertain the first appeal, leaving applicants in a state of uncertainty and frustration.
Consequently, this has forced individuals to resort to filing a second appeal before the Uttar Pradesh Information Commission, a process that is often lengthy and burdensome, further indicating a systemic issue in handling RTI requests.
The unresponsiveness not only undermines the purpose of the Right to Information Act but also discourages citizens from seeking information that is their right, thereby stifling civic engagement and participation in governance.
📌 Appeal Registration Number: A-20241200240
Filed By: Yogi M. P. Singh
Date of Filing: 04 December 2024.
Location: Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh
Department Concerned: Rural Development Department (District Level)
Office: District Development Officer in Mirzapur. This is the office. It is crucial in any DDO Mirzapur related case.
🧾 Background of the Case
The appellant, Yogi M. P. Singh, submitted an RTI application on 21 September 2024 (Registration No. COMRD/R/2024/60233) seeking detailed posting information of staff in the City Block Development Office, Mirzapur. The information requested included: the names of the staff members currently working in that office, their designations, the duration of their postings, and the specific roles they fulfill in serving the public.
Furthermore, Yogi expressed a keen interest in understanding how these postings align with government regulations and the overall efficiency of local governance. He believed that transparency in the staffing of such critical offices is essential for ensuring accountability and improving service delivery to the residents of Mirzapur.
In light of recent discussions regarding bureaucratic efficiency, this inquiry also aimed to shed light on the adequacy of resources allocated to this office, which plays a pivotal role in community development and public welfare.
- First posting details of the Block Development Officer.
- Date of joining in Mirzapur and initial post.
- Posting details of Class 2, Class 3, and Class 4 employees including dates of joining in the district and at the block.
Despite the RTI application being received, no response was provided by the Public Information Officer (PIO), Mr. Shravan Kumar Rai, who oversees issues such as those related to DDO Mirzapur.
📣 First Appeal Ignored
A first appeal was filed on 31 October 2024 (Appeal No. COMRD/A/2024/60317) to the First Appellate Authority (FAA), Mr. Vishal Kumar (IAS), who serves as the Chief Development Officer of Mirzapur.
This appeal was prompted by a lack of response to an earlier request, highlighting the pressing need for transparency and accountability in the administrative process.
Unfortunately, despite the earnest nature of the appeal and the supporting documentation provided, this too was not entertained, and alarmingly, no order or reply was issued by the hierarchy, including the DDO Mirzapur office, leaving the appellant in a state of uncertainty and frustration regarding the resolution of their concerns.
This situation underscores the challenges faced by citizens seeking information and illustrates the need for improvements in the responsiveness of public officials to appeals made under the Right to Information Act.
⚖️ Grounds for Second Appeal
The appellant has now approached the Uttar Pradesh Information Commission under Section 19(3) of the RTI Act, citing a series of concerns regarding the lack of transparency and accountability in the handling of his earlier requests for information.
This move reflects a growing apprehension among citizens about their right to access information and the need for government bodies to uphold their obligations under the law.
The appellant believes that the Commission has a pivotal role to play in ensuring that these rights are respected and enforced, thereby fostering a culture of openness and responsiveness within public administration.
As the situation unfolds, stakeholders are keenly watching to see how the Commission will address these issues and what steps will be taken to rectify the ongoing inefficiencies in the system.
- Non-compliance by both PIO and FAA.
- Violation of transparency and accountability principles enshrined in the RTI Act regarding Mirzapur DDO affairs.
- Suspected corruption due to prolonged postings and lack of staff rotation in the City Block Development Office.
🙏 Relief Sought
The appellant has requested the Hon’ble Commission to consider their appeal thoroughly and take into account all relevant evidence and circumstances surrounding the case, ensuring that every aspect is meticulously reviewed to uphold the principles of justice and fairness that the Commission stands for.
- Invoke Section 20 of the RTI Act to impose pecuniary penalty on the PIO.
- Initiate disciplinary proceedings against the FAA for failing to discharge duties. This is noted as a crucial step in resolving DDO Mirzapur issues.
- Ensure disclosure of the requested information to uphold the spirit of the RTI Act.
📍 Contact Details of Respondents
PIO: Shravan Kumar Rai
📞 9454465108 | ✉️ ddomirzapur123@gmail.com
FAA: Vishal Kumar (IAS)
📞 9454465106 | ✉️ drda-mir@nic.in
🗣️ Final Words from the Appellant
“The RTI Act was enacted to combat corruption and promote transparency. Still, the current scenario reflects how deeply corruption has infiltrated the framework, even obstructing the implementation of this vital law.”
Which are crucial for understanding the DDO Mirzapur actions.BDO City did not provide transfer and posting details of staff in City Block.
BDO City may provide transfer and posting details of staff in City Block,
Facing a similar challenge? Share the details in the box below, and our team of experts will do their best to help.