Accountability Questioned: Grievance Filed Over Mirzapur Police Station’s RTI Response

The Uttar Pradesh government received a grievance questioning the handling of a Right to Information (RTI) request. The Drummond Ganj police station in Mirzapur managed this request, raising important points about the Mirzapur Police & RTI Response. The complainant, Sadhana Tiwari, alleges that the Station House Officer (SHO) improperly deflected the request. This raises concerns about transparency. It also questions the competence of personnel in key administrative posts.
In her formal complaint, Tiwari emphasises that such actions undermine the integrity of the RTI process. They also complicate the public’s ability to access vital information.
Notably, Sadhana Tiwari’s filing highlights these significant issues. It highlights the necessity for accountability. It also emphasises the importance of efficient communication between law enforcement agencies and the citizens they serve.
Furthermore, she calls for a thorough investigation into the matter. She asserts that this could initiate necessary reforms within the local police department.

Grievance Details (Mirzapur Police & RTI Response)

It is obvious that the Station House Officer of Drummond Ganj submits arbitrary and inconsistent reports. These reports raise serious concerns about the integrity of his findings. These reports raise serious concerns about the integrity of his findings.
The applicant is submitting multiple grievances because of this troubling situation. Each grievance details instances where the reports fail to capture the true nature of events.
These discrepancies undermine the credibility of the investigations. They also contribute to a growing atmosphere of frustration. This atmosphere fosters distrust among those affected.
As the applicant seeks resolution, it becomes increasingly clear. A thorough review of the reports is essential. Evaluating the processes behind them is crucial. This ensures that faith is restored in the system. It also ensures that justice is served.

• Registration Number: GOVUP/E/2024/0093166
• Complainant Name: Sadhana Tiwari, central to this grievance.
• Date of Receipt: 19/12/2024
• Concerned Department: Uttar Pradesh

Background: The Original RTI Request

The grievance stems from a response to an RTI application filed in November 2024. During this time, Sadhana Tiwari sought answers directly related to specific administrative issues, which shows her involvement in seeking transparency.
Her initiative is commendable. It reflects a broader concern shared by many citizens about the need for accountability within local governance. Sadhana is dedicated to public welfare. Her persistent quest for clarity underscores the importance of grassroots activism. It highlights the role of grassroots movements in addressing bureaucratic inefficiencies.
She navigated the complexities of the administrative framework with determination. Her efforts inspired others in the community to become more engaged and informed about their rights. This encouraged a collective movement towards transparency. This movement resonated beyond her individual case and promoted justice. This movement resonated beyond her individual case and promoted justice.

• RTI Registration Number: SPMZR/R/2024/60220
• Date of Filing: 21/11/2024
• Public Information Officer (PIO) Details:
  • Name: Om Prakash Singh
  • Designation: ASP Operation
  • Phone No.: 9125608556
  • Email ID: aspopmzp@gmail.com

The Core Issue: The Police Station’s Response

According to the grievance, the SHO of Drummond Ganj
police station responded to the RTI request. The SHO stated that the information sought is not available at the local station level. It should be obtained from the Police Headquarters in Mirzapur.
This response raises questions about the accessibility of information within the local law enforcement framework. It has also led Sadhana Tiwari to question local administrative processes. Her persistent efforts through the RTI have highlighted significant gaps in accountability.
Furthermore, Tiwari’s determination to hold authorities accountable highlights transparency issues within the police system. It reflects the ongoing struggle between citizens seeking justice. Institutional barriers often hinder their efforts.
This situation emphasizes civic participation’s necessity. It is crucial for advocating for change. It ensures that governance responds to its constituents.

The official report, dated 11/12/2024, states:

“…the information sought by the applicant Sadhna Tiwari... is not due from the local police station. It would be justified to obtain the information sought from Police Headquarters Mirzapur.”

Information Sought in the RTI Application (Mirzapur Police & RTI Response)

Sadhana Tiwari, the complainant, highlights that she explicitly directed the RTI query at the Drummond Ganj police station. She requested seven points of information, which provide evidence for this.

1. The Police Station Drummond Ganj has registered the number of N.C.R. (Non-Cognizable Reports) during the current financial year. The same applies to the number of F.I.R. (First Information Reports) registered during this period. Additionally, information regarding the number of cases under preventive sections, such as Cr.P.C. 107/116/151 or corresponding BNS sections, has also been compiled.
2. The Police Station Drummond Ganj incurred fuel expenses for diesel and petrol. These expenses are for the financial years 2021-22, 2022-23, and 2023-24 (figures only).
3. Posting details and the official C.U.G. mobile number of the current Station House Officer at Police Station Drummond Ganj. This includes their date of joining in the Mirzapur district.
4. Posting details and official mobile numbers of all Sub-Inspectors at Police Station Drummond Ganj. These details include their names and joining dates in the district.
5. Posting details of all Police Constables at the Police Station Drummond Ganj are available. These include their names and joining dates in the district.
6. Details of funds spent on painting and whitewashing at Police Station Drummond Ganj in the last five years.
7. Government funds were spent on electricity bills at Police Station Drummond Ganj. These expenses cover the financial years 2021-22, 2022-23, 2023-24, and the current financial year. (figures only).

The complainant argues that every question specifically names the police station. The SHO’s response tries to evade transparency and accountability. This was the primary reason Sadhana Tiwari initiated the grievance.

Current Status of the Grievance

The grievance has been officially received. It was forwarded for review. This process started largely due to Sadhana Tiwari’s insistence on transparency. (Mirzapur Police & RTI Response)

• Current Status: Grievance received
• Date of Action: 19/12/2024
• Forwarded To Officer Details:
  • Officer Name: Shri Arvind Mohan (Joint Secretary)
  • Organisation: Uttar Pradesh
  • Contact Address: Chief Minister Secretariat, Room No. 321, U.P. Secretariat, Lucknow
  • Email Address: arvind.12574@gov.in
  • Contact Number: 05222226350

RTI Application Insights for Mirzapur Police Station – Yogi as an anti-corruption crusader

Sadhna Tiwari requests government to register First Information Report, reinforcing the importance of transparency.

Grievances concerning SHO Drummondganj redressed by SDM Lalganj