Key Takeaways (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
- The case of Naresh Kumar Jaiswal highlights systemic failures under the RTI Act in Mirzapur. The Revenue Department has ignored requests for over 120 days.
- Key issues include facilitating property fraud through inaction. They also involve character assassination tactics against the appellant’s father. Additionally, there is a failure of the appellate authority.
- The appellant demands intervention from the Uttar Pradesh Information Commission, seeking penalties against officials and immediate access to land records.
- This case represents a critical test for the RTI Act in Uttar Pradesh. Prolonged silence undermines transparency. It also affects citizens’ rights to ancestral property.
- Essential preparations for the upcoming online hearing include technical setup. They also involve strategic questioning for the PIO. Additionally, there is a readiness to counter false claims of mental instability.
RTI Act in Mirzapur: Transparency vs. Revenue Negligence in Mirzapur
The Core Conflict: Land, Law, and Silence
The case of Naresh Kumar Jaiswal vs. PIO/ Vishal Kumar Sharma, Tehsil Sadar (Mirzapur) is not just a simple RTI delay. It is a battle against the deliberate withholding of information. This withholding aims to facilitate property encroachment. While the RTI Act mandates a response within 30 days, the Mirzapur Revenue Department has remained silent. This silence has extended for over 120 days. This silence has effectively paralysed his family’s future.
Key Issues at Stake (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
1. Facilitating Property Fraud through Inaction
The main complaint states that someone sold ancestral property without completing a legal partition. The Tehsildar Sadar (PIO) refuses to provide certified records. They also withhold official communication channels. This indirectly allows the illegal alienation of land.
2. Character Assassination as a Tactic
A deeply concerning aspect of this case is the appellant’s father’s attempt. He tries to declare a qualified Commerce Graduate as “mentally unstable.”This tactic allows individuals to bypass legal consent requirements for property sales. The RTI requested is the only shield the appellant has to prove his legal standing. (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
3. The Failure of the Appellate Machinery (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
The First Appellate Authority (SDM Sadar) has failed to exercise its statutory duty under Section 19(1). This “double failure” of both the PIO and the FAA indicates a systemic breakdown of accountability in the Mirzapur Tehsil.
Legal Standing & Demands
The appellant is seeking the intervention of the Uttar Pradesh Information Commission (Bench S-11) on the following grounds:
- Deemed Refusal: Under Section 7(2), silence is a legal refusal.
- Mandatory Penalty: A request for a ₹25,000 penalty on Shri Vishal Kumar Sharma (Tehsildar) for willful obstruction of the law.
- Property Protection: Official emails and land records should be released immediately. This is to serve legal notices to the District Magistrate and SP Mirzapur. (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
Conclusion: A Test for the RTI Act (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
This case serves as a critical test for the RTI Act in Uttar Pradesh. If a PIO can ignore an application for four months, it undermines the very purpose of “Transparency.” A citizen’s ancestral rights should not be sold away. The eyes of the public are now on the Commission’s decision for the hearing on December 23, 2025.
Final Advice for Tomorrow’s Online Hearing
- Be the First to Speak: When commission takes up proceedings, immediately mention the Diary Number (D-221220250081).. Inform the court that you have emailed your representation to the court email today.
- Highlight the Malice: Use the phrase “Malafide Intent.” Tell the Commissioner that the PIO is not just “lazy.” The PIO is “intentionally silent” to help your father sell the property.
- Demand a Daily Penalty: Remind the Commissioner that under Section 20(1), the penalty is a statutory requirement. Impose the penalty for delay once they prove it without reasonable cause. (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
To help you prepare for tomorrow’s online hearing on December 23, 2025, follow these steps. Be ready to ask the critical questions.
1. Technical Guide for Joining the Online Hearing (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
UPIC typically uses Jitsi Meet for its online benches.
- Accessing the Link: * Open the UPIC Weekly Cause List.
- Look for Room S-11 (Bench of Shri Veirendra Pratap Singh).
- There is usually a “Join” or “VC Link” button next to the bench name. It becomes active 15–30 minutes before the session starts. This is around 10:30 AM – 11:00 AM.
- On Mobile:
- Download the “Jitsi Meet” app from the Play Store/App Store tonight.
- When you click the link tomorrow, it will ask to open in the app. Choose the app for better stability.
- Rename yourself: As soon as you join, set your display name to “Naresh Kumar Jaiswal (Appellant)”.
2. Three Strategic Questions for the PIO
If the Tehsildar (Shri Vishal Kumar Sharma) or his representative joins the call, ask these questions specifically to highlight their malafide intent to the Commissioner:
- “Can the PIO provide the Speed Post tracking number for any reply sent to me within the 30-day legal window?” (They likely have no reply, which proves “Deemed Refusal” u/s 7(2).)
- “On what legal grounds did the PIO ‘not entertain’ an RTI application delivered via registered channels?” (This highlights a violation of Sec 18 and justifies the ₹25,000 penalty.)
- “Is the PIO aware that their administrative silence is actively allowing the illegal sale of ancestral property? This occurs while a Family Court case is pending.” (This connects the delay to the real-world harm you are suffering.)
3. If your Father’s “Lunacy” Claim is raised (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
If the PIO tries to defend their inaction by claiming you are “mentally unstable” (based on your father’s false statements):
- Immediately say: “Sir, I am a Commerce Graduate. I have emailed my B.Com degree to
hearingcourts11.upic@up.gov.intoday. This claim is a fraudulent tactic. My father wants to grab property, and the PIO is assisting him by staying silent.”
Final Checklist for 10:30 AM Tomorrow:
- [ ] Phone Charge: 100%.
- [ ] Data: Ensure you have high-speed internet.
- [ ] Documents: Keep your RTI Receipt, B.Com degree, and the representation you emailed today on the table.
- [ ] Quiet Space: Sit in a room with no background noise.
To ensure you’re fully prepared for tomorrow’s hearing, gather the essential IDs. You will also find links and contact numbers.They structure the information for quick reference.
1. Case Identification & Portal Details
These are the numbers that identify your legal standing. Have them written on a piece of paper during the call. (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
- Registration Number:
A-20251101309 - File Number:
S11/A/2094/2025 - Diary Number:
D-221220250081 - Applied Date: 17/11/2025
- UPIC User ID:
UPICR20250006190
2. Official Video Hearing Links
The UP Information Commission has updated its protocol. Please note the software requirement below:
- Primary Web Link:UPIC Weekly Cause List
- How to use: Tomorrow morning, go to this link. Find Bench S-11. Then, click the “Join” button next to your case number.
- Required Software:Microsoft Teams (as per latest UPIC notice).
- Action: Download “Microsoft Teams” from the Play Store/App Store today.
- Naming Format: When you join the meeting, set your name as: NARESH KUMAR JAISWAL / S11 / A / 2094 / 2025
3. Contact Directory (Emails & Mobiles) (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
Use these to follow up if there are technical glitches tomorrow.
| Authority / Office | Official Email | Mobile / CUG |
| S-11 Hearing Court | hearingcourts11.upic@up.gov.in | — |
| UPIC Registrar | registrar-upic@up.gov.in | 0522-2724930 |
| Tehsildar Sadar (PIO) | teh-sadar.mi@up.gov.in | 9454416823 |
| SDM Sadar (FAA) | sdm-sadar.mi@up.gov.in | 9454416810 |
| SP Mirzapur | spmzr-up@nic.in | 9454400299 |
4. Digital Representation Summary (RTI Act in Mirzapur)
Since you have already emailed your representation, your focus tomorrow should be on oral confirmation.
Key Reminder for Tomorrow:
- Unmute only when asked. Use the “Raise Hand” feature in Microsoft Teams. Do this if the PIO (Tehsildar) tries to give false information.
- If the Commissioner asks for your documents, respond by saying: “Sir, I have sent my complete representation. I also sent proof of educational qualifications to hearingcourts11.upic@up.gov.in at 8:11 PM on Dec 22.”
Would you like me to guide you on how to “Screen Share” your B.Com degree directly from your phone during the Microsoft Teams meeting if the Commissioner asks to see it?
Facing a similar challenge? Share the details in the box below, and our team of experts will do their best to help.