Table of contents
- Introduction: LDA block an RTI inquiry
- Here are the key takeaways from the document:
- 33 Months of Defiance: How the LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry
- The Plot Allotment Dispute in Kanpur Road Scheme
- LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry: Claims of Missing Papers vs. Postal Records
- Six Clear Questions and 33 Months of Delays
- How the LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry by Ignoring Appeals
- Unrelated Files and Misapplied Rules
- The Final Hearing : Why the LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry and Penalties Sought
- Official Case Reference and Contact Information
- Related Posts: LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry
Introduction: LDA block an RTI inquiry
Discover how the Lucknow Development Authority (LDA) has blocked an RTI inquiry into land plot allotments over a 33-month battle, raising questions about transparency, accountability, and the accessibility of public records. The prolonged dispute highlights the challenges faced by citizens seeking information from government agencies and examines the events, responses, and unanswered concerns surrounding the case.
Here are the key takeaways from the document:
- Prolonged Defiance: The Lucknow Development Authority (LDA) has spent 33 months blocking an RTI inquiry concerning land plot allotments in the Kanpur Road Scheme. Furthermore, officials continue to refuse to share basic public records.
- Ignored Orders: Throughout this dispute, the LDA has disregarded directives from the First Appellate Authority, multiple orders from the State Information Commission, and a formal warning from the Divisional Commissioner.
- Evasive Tactics: Instead of answering the straightforward questions, LDA staff relied on baseless claims of missing paperwork, misapplied rules, and unrelated files from entirely different cases.
- Upcoming Final Hearing: Consequently, this battle has reached a crucial stage, with State Information Commissioner Shri Padum Narayan Dwivedi setting a final hearing for 25 November 2026 in Court Room S-5.
- Demand for Accountability: Finally, because of the persistent delays and direct refusal to comply, the applicant is pressing for full penalties, disciplinary actions, and compensation under the RTI Act.
33 Months of Defiance: How the LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry
Public authorities in Uttar Pradesh often promise open government and fair service. However, a 33-month battle reveals how the LDA blocked an RTI inquiry into land plot allotments. Indeed, the Lucknow Development Authority still refuses to share basic public records. Furthermore, it has ignored one directive from the First Appellate Authority, four orders from the State Information Commission, and a warning from the Divisional Commissioner.
As a result, this dispute has now reached a key moment. On 25 November 2026, State Information Commissioner Shri Padum Narayan Dwivedi will hold a final hearing in Court Room S-5. In preparation, applicant Yogi M. P. Singh filed his written response on 22 November 2026 under Diary Number D-221120260016. Moreover, reviewing this case shows how delays, wrong rules, and evasive paperwork harm the Right to Information Act of 2005.
The Plot Allotment Dispute in Kanpur Road Scheme
Every RTI request comes from a real issue. In this case, the dispute involves five land plots in Sector-H of the Kanpur Road Scheme in Lucknow. Specifically, these are plots SS-1914, SS-1915, SS-1916, SS-1917, and SS-1918.
For context, formal complaints show that the Allahabad High Court issued an order on 7 March 2006 regarding rights to these plots. The court asked the claimant to get an official title declaration from a competent court. However, LDA staff bypassed this court order. Instead, they registered the plots for buyers who lacked original papers.
In addition, the complaints point out clear errors in the agency records. Official entries list a father as 30 years old, a mother as 25 years old, and their son as 18 years old. Clearly, such impossible age gaps require a proper review rather than silence.
LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry: Claims of Missing Papers vs. Postal Records
Initially, citizens raised this issue under tracking number GOVUP/E/2024/0006965. In response, LDA Deputy Secretary Atul Krishna Singh closed the case on 17 February 2024 through Letter 220. Specifically, he claimed that the involved parties failed to send papers or meet with the inquiry team.
However, clear evidence contradicts his claim. First, Yogi M. P. Singh had already attached a 24-page file to the online complaint. Second, 73-year-old Shri Dinesh Pratap Singh, a retired newspaper editor, sent physical proof to the LDA by registered mail multiple times.
How the LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry from an Older Citizen
Specifically, between September 2022 and December 2023, Shri Dinesh Pratap Singh sent four letters to LDA officers. For instance, he wrote registered letters on 11 September 2022, 13 December 2022, and 28 January 2023 to Nazul Officer Arvind Tripathi and Officer Ram Shankar. In these letters, he explained that health issues prevented him from traveling from Mirzapur to Lucknow.
Therefore, he offered a practical solution. He proposed to show all original papers to an officer at the Mirzapur agency, or pay for an LDA staff member to visit Mirzapur. Moreover, on 9 December 2023, he mailed a 45-page packet with the High Court order and plot records. Postal records for item EU950794838IN prove that the Mirzapur post office accepted the parcel on 11 December 2023. The Gomti Nagar office then delivered it to the LDA on 16 December 2023. Consequently, LDA staff had no basis to claim papers were missing.
Six Clear Questions and 33 Months of Delays
In order to resolve this issue, Yogi M. P. Singh filed RTI request LKDPA/R/2024/60105 on 18 February 2024. Specifically, he asked the LDA Public Information Officer (PIO) six specific questions:
- The reason for withholding the 24-page file from the inquiry team.
- The names and roles of LDA staff assigned to accept papers for the team.
- Details of actions taken on Shri Dinesh Pratap Singh’s letter from 9 December 2023, backed by postal delivery proof.
- Details of actions taken on Shri Dinesh Pratap Singh’s letters from 28 January 2023, 11 September 2022, and 13 December 2022.
Section 7(1) of the RTI Act requires a PIO to reply within 30 days. Nevertheless, the LDA PIO did not respond at all.
How the LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry by Ignoring Appeals
Because the PIO missed the deadline, the applicant filed First Appeal LKDPA/A/2024/60087 on 21 April 2024. Subsequently, on 30 May 2024, First Appellate Authority Gyanendra Verma reviewed the case. He noted that the agency had no proof of sending a reply. Thus, he ordered PIO Atul Krishna to provide the details within 15 days. However, the PIO ignored this direct order from his supervisor.
Next, the applicant turned to the State Information Commission. He filed Second Appeal S05/A/0518/2024 on 22 July 2024. Subsequently, a series of ignored orders followed:
- 28 November 2024: Court Room S-5 ordered the PIO to send all requested info within two weeks or face daily fines.
- 19 May 2025: The Commission repeated its instruction and gave a final deadline.
- 24 February 2026: Due to ongoing delays, the Commission issued a Show Cause Notice and asked the LDA Vice-Chairman to step in.
- 9 June 2026: The Commission issued another notice and asked the Divisional Commissioner of Lucknow to force compliance.
- 20 July 2026: Following the order, Administrative Officer Piyush Kumar Gupta sent Letter 3534, telling the PIO to comply right away.
Despite these steps, the LDA provided no answers and failed to attend the hearing on 22 September 2026.
Unrelated Files and Misapplied Rules
Instead of providing public records, LDA staff used two main tactics to stall the process.
First, after holding the request for 15 months, PIO Hemchandra Tiwari rejected it on 23 May 2025. He cited Rule 4(2)(b)(ii), claiming the request required new analysis or opinions. However, this excuse does not hold up legally. Requesting action reports and staff names seeks existing records under Section 2(f) of the RTI Act, not personal opinions.
Second, in September 2025, LDA staff submitted four letters signed by Under Secretary Sanjeev Kumar and Officer Ravi Nandan Singh. Crucially, all four letters belonged to completely different appeal cases. Consequently, none of them answered the six questions in request LKDPA/R/2024/60105. Instead, they reused old excuses about missing papers to give a false impression of progress.
The Final Hearing: Why the LDA Blocked an RTI Inquiry and Penalties Sought
Since neither side attended on 22 September 2026, the Commission set a final hearing for 25 November 2026. To avoid confusion, Yogi M. P. Singh submitted his full response on 22 November 2026 by email and through the online portal, detailing the complete case history.
In conclusion, this case clearly shows how the LDA blocked an RTI inquiry and tested the limits of legal enforcement. Under Section 7(6) of the RTI Act, an applicant has a right to free information once the 30-day period passes. Furthermore, 33 months of delays, a baseless rejection, and direct refusal to comply warrant full penalties under Section 20(1), disciplinary steps under Section 20(2), and compensation under Section 19(8)(b). Enforcing these rules protects every citizen’s right to monitor public agencies.
Official Case Reference and Contact Information
- Original RTI Application: LKDPA/R/2024/60105 (Filed: 18 February 2024)
- First Appeal Number: LKDPA/A/2024/60087 (Order dated: 30 May 2024)
- Second Appeal & Registration No.: S05/A/0518/2024 / A-20240701671 (Filed: 22 July 2024)
- Latest Portal Diary Number: D-221120260016 (Submitted: 22 November 2026)
- Related Grievance & Postal Proof: GOVUP/E/2024/0006965 | India Post Consignment EU950794838IN
- Uttar Pradesh Information Commission (Court Room S-5): hearingcourts5.upic@up.gov.in | Portal: https://upsic.up.gov.in/
- PIO, Lucknow Development Authority (Deputy Secretary Atul Krishna): Mobile: 9918001893 | Email: raz.9125@gmail.com
- PIO, Lucknow Development Authority (Hemchandra Tiwari, Chakbandi Adhikari): Mobile: 9918005512 | Email: hemtiwari071@gmail.com
- First Appellate Authority, LDA (Gyanendra Verma, Additional Secretary): Mobile: 9918001927 | Email: ldartionline@gmail.com
- Office of the Divisional Commissioner, Lucknow: Email: commluc@nic.in | Compliance Letter No. 3534/जनसूचना-189/2025-26 dated 20 July 2026


Facing a similar challenge? Share the details in the box below, and our team of experts will do their best to help.