Table of contents
- Introduction: Digital Governance & Digital Evasion
- Digital Governance & Digital Evasion: Inside Mirzapur’s Battle Over Civic Neglect, Feedback OTPs, and Vanishing RTI Portals
- 1. The Ground Reality: Three Unresolved Civic Hazards in Surekapuram Colony
- 2. Hijacking Citizen Feedback: Digital Governance & Digital Evasion via OTP Extraction
- 3. Judge in His Own Cause: Procedural Bypasses, Fabricated Subjects, and Blurred Sweeper Photos
- 4. Missing Contacts: Digital Governance & Digital Evasion in the UP Online RTI Portal
- 5. Steps to Improve Accountability and Prevent Digital Evasion in Public Systems
- Case Reference Directory: Application IDs, Official Contacts & Portal Links
- Related Posts: Digital Governance & Digital Evasion
Introduction: Digital Governance & Digital Evasion
Explore the vital role of Digital Governance & Digital Evasion in enhancing public service and citizen engagement by examining how digital technologies can improve transparency, accessibility, efficiency, and accountability. Discover how governments can use online platforms, data-driven systems, and innovative communication tools to deliver services more effectively, while also considering the challenges of the digital divide, privacy, cybersecurity, misinformation, and the ways individuals or institutions may avoid, bypass, or resist digital systems.
Key Takeaways
- Digital Governance & Digital Evasion plays a crucial role in improving public services and citizen engagement through technology.
- Mirzapur’s digital initiatives faced significant failures, showcasing administrative neglect and loss of public trust.
- Key unresolved civic issues include severe waterlogging, unpaved roads, and broken promises on park improvements.
- The Jansunwai portal’s feedback system was compromised by OTP extraction, undermining accountability.
- Authorities must investigate OTP misuse, enhance the RTI portal, reject invalid complaint closures, and complete civic repairs for improved trust.
Digital Governance & Digital Evasion: Inside Mirzapur’s Battle Over Civic Neglect, Feedback OTPs, and Vanishing RTI Portals
Initially, digital portals like Uttar Pradesh’s Jansunwai (IGRS) and the UP Online RTI Portal were established to promote genuine Digital Governance & Digital Evasion awareness and transparent public service. Ultimately, they aimed to connect citizens directly to the government. Furthermore, they were built to remove delays and ensure clear accountability. On paper, officials continuously track every complaint. Subsequently, citizens verify each resolution with feedback, while the Right to Information Act of 2005 keeps public authorities answerable.
However, recent events in Surekapuram Colony, Mirzapur, clearly show how easily these digital tools can fail. To begin with, the issue started with simple requests for local infrastructure, such as proper drainage, safe roads, and a park. Soon after, it grew into serious systemic problems. For instance, residents reported unauthorized requests for Jansunwai Feedback OTPs. Meanwhile, officials closed complaints using blurry, unrelated photos. In addition, Mirzapur’s municipal Public Information Officers disappeared from the state RTI portal altogether.
As a result, this case highlights a growing tension between digital governance & digital evasion. Indeed, it illustrates how official neglect adapts to the digital age.
1. The Ground Reality: Three Unresolved Civic Hazards in Surekapuram Colony
Currently, three clear civic problems remain unresolved in Surekapuram Colony under Nagar Palika Parishad, Mirzapur. Specifically, these issues were raised across three separate filings: GOVUP/E/2026/0112205, GOVUP/E/2026/0128466, and GOVUP/E/2026/0144385:
- Severe Waterlogging: First, pipeline work raised the main road junction by six feet. Consequently, this change trapped rainwater in the neighborhood. Although residents asked for a simple temporary drain (mori), officials nevertheless ignored the request.
- Unsafe, Uncompacted Roads: Second, workers dug trenches for utilities and filled them with loose soil. However, they did not pack the soil down or pave it. As a result, the street quickly became dangerous for walking and driving.
- Unfulfilled Park Promise: Third, on 14 February 2023, officials signed a report promising to improve the Second Park using 15th Finance Commission funds. Nevertheless, more than three years later, no work has actually been done.
In the meantime, officials did not inspect the area or provide a work schedule. Instead, they prematurely closed Grievance No. GOVUP/E/2026/0128466 on 28 October 2026. Consequently, this routine failure grew into a prime example of administrative neglect and digital evasion, directly undermining public trust.
2. Hijacking Citizen Feedback: Digital Governance & Digital Evasion via OTP Extraction
In theory, the Jansunwai portal uses an OTP feedback system to stop improper complaint closures. Specifically, a rating from a citizen is meant to verify that real work actually took place.
However, when the complainant tried to submit negative feedback for GOVUP/E/2026/0128466, OTP messages arrived on his phone unexpectedly. For example, he received OTP 45252 at 12:02 and OTP 65723 at 21:51. Simultaneously, phone calls came from 07398538000 (listed as Saurabh Jaiswal on Truecaller). In particular, the calls included a missed call at 12:03 as well as two answered calls at 12:23 and 12:26.
Subsequently, a formal complaint was filed on 2 November 2026 (GOVUP/E/2026/0144385 / Ref: 60000260305479). Importantly, it noted that the caller explicitly asked for the OTP to enter positive feedback. Furthermore, the caller stated he was calling directly on behalf of the Executive Officer of Nagar Palika Parishad, Mirzapur.
Fortunately, the complainant refused to share the code. Indeed, asking for a user’s OTP directly breaks safety rules. Furthermore, if staff illicitly take feedback OTPs from citizens, portal ratings become entirely inaccurate, thereby displaying false high satisfaction scores.
3. Judge in His Own Cause: Procedural Bypasses, Fabricated Subjects, and Blurred Sweeper Photos
Initially, the citizen provided clear proof, including call logs and OTP text screenshots. Because these files showed staff actively trying to bypass portal checks, standard rules require a higher officer to review such claims.
Instead, the closing of GOVUP/E/2026/0144385 on 17 November 2026 fundamentally broke basic rules of fair review in several ways:
- Self-Investigation Conflict: First, the complaint explicitly named the Executive Officer of Nagar Palika Parishad, Mirzapur. Yet, the system assigned the complaint to that same officer for review. Consequently, the officer cleared his own office and closed the case.
- Partial Admission: Second, in a report to the District Magistrate, the Executive Officer admitted that staff call users for feedback. However, the report did not explain why OTPs were generated or who asked for them in the first place.
- Changed Subject Line: Third, the final report completely ignored OTP issues, waterlogging, and roads. Instead, it listed a completely new title: “Cleaning and garbage disposal in Danghar Ward No. 06.”
- Blurry Photos Attached: Finally, the closure included four blurry photos dated 14 November 2026. Meanwhile, the images showed a worker sweeping dust. Moreover, the locations and times were unreadable, and sweeping was entirely unrelated to the complaint.
Nevertheless, higher offices accepted the closure note without checking the facts. Ultimately, this action suggests that serious issues can easily be dismissed using unrelated photos, demonstrating a severe lapse in digital governance & digital evasion practices.
4. Missing Contacts: Digital Governance & Digital Evasion in the UP Online RTI Portal
Next, the citizen used the Right to Information Act, 2005. Specifically, on 20 November 2026, he logged onto rtionline.up.gov.in to submit an RTI query (DIRLB/R/2026/61125). In doing so, he asked for reasons behind the blurry photos, details on staff members, and copies of official call orders.
However, the official RTI portal suffered from major layout errors, presenting another barrier to transparency through systemic digital evasion.
For example, under the Local Bodies Directorate, choosing Mirzapur District does not show local municipal offices. Instead, the menu lists only one misspelled entry from another district: “EO NPP Robrtsganj Sonbhadra”. Meanwhile, Sonbhadra’s list has duplicate names, and Bhadohi lists only one office.
In general, Department Nodal Officers are responsible for updating PIO lists. Thus, when entire districts are missing, citizens cannot submit queries online. Consequently, the applicant sent a second RTI (DOUDV/R/2026/61224) to the Urban Development Department. Even so, portal limits stop automatic transfers to missing offices, thereby creating extra delays for users.
5. Steps to Improve Accountability and Prevent Digital Evasion in Public Systems
Ultimately, this situation shows that technology alone cannot fix administrative issues. Indeed, digital systems work only when senior managers check reports carefully and maintain online lists correctly.
Therefore, to rebuild public trust, authorities should take four clear actions:
- Investigate OTP Use: First, senior officers must review improper OTP requests. Furthermore, they should issue strict rules banning staff from asking for citizen OTPs.
- Reject Invalid Closures: Second, supervisors must reject reports that change topic details or use blurry images. In addition, they should discipline staff who submit misleading files.
- Fix the RTI Portal: Third, the Department of Administrative Reforms should audit rtionline.up.gov.in. Specifically, they must add missing offices like Nagar Palika Parishad Mirzapur and ensure lists stay up to date.
- Complete Ground Repairs: Finally, real success requires physical work. Therefore, teams must construct the drain outlet, level the road, and carry out the park updates pledged in 2023.
In conclusion, without strict checks, tactics of Digital Governance & Digital Evasion will defeat the core purpose of institutional initiatives designed to protect citizen rights.
Case Reference Directory: Application IDs, Official Contacts & Portal Links
1. Grievance & RTI Application IDs
- Original Civic Grievance (CPGRAMS/UP): GOVUP/E/2026/0112205
- Follow-up Grievance (Arbitrarily Closed on 28/10/2026): GOVUP/E/2026/0128466
- Complaint Against OTP Fraud & Civic Neglect (Filed 02/11/2026; Closed 17/11/2026): GOVUP/E/2026/0144385
- Linked Jansunwai / IGRS Reference Number: 60000260305479 (Dated 02/11/2026)
- RTI Application No. 1 (Local Bodies Directorate, Filed 20/11/2026): DIRLB/R/2026/61125 (Online Payment Ref: CPAHNQIFN2)
- RTI Application No. 2 (Urban Development Department, Filed 20/11/2026): DOUDV/R/2026/61224 (Online Payment Ref: CPAHNQQOY0)
2. Concerned Public Authorities & Official Contact Details for Governance Audit
- Chief Minister Secretariat, Government of Uttar Pradesh
- Officer: Shri Bhaskar Chandra Kandpal, Joint Secretary
- Office Address: Room No. 321, U.P. Secretariat, Lucknow
- Email: bhaskar.31532@gov.in
- Phone: 0522-2226350
- Urban Development Department (Nagar Vikas), Government of Uttar Pradesh
- Nodal Officer: Mobile 9454412780 | Email: so.nagarvikas8@gmail.com
- Public Information Officer (PIO): Shri Akhileshwar Singh (NV-5), Section Officer | Mobile 9454414051 | Email: so.nagar.05@gmail.com
- Directorate of Local Bodies, Uttar Pradesh
- Nodal Officer: Phone 6388971772 | Email: diruplb@nic.in
- Nagar Palika Parishad, Mirzapur (Concerned Municipal Authority)
- Executive Officer (EO): Nagar Palika Parishad, Mirzapur (Currently omitted from the Mirzapur District dropdown on the UP Online RTI Portal)
- Regional In-charge Safai Nayak (Danghar Ward No. 06, cited in disposal report): Shri Umesh | Mobile: 6307677978
- Number Identified in OTP Solicitation Evidence: 07398538000 (Identified via Truecaller as Saurabh Jaiswal)
- Nagar Palika Parishad, Robertsganj, Sonbhadra(Erroneously Mapped Under Mirzapur District on RTI Portal)
- PIO: Executive Officer, NPP Robertsganj, Sonbhadra (Listed on portal as EO NPP Robrtsganj Sonbhadra)
- Mobile: 9621539294
- Email: nagarpalikaparishadsonbhadra@gmail.com
3. Official Web Links
- CPGRAMS (Centralized Public Grievance Redress and Monitoring System): https://pgportal.gov.in/
- UP Jansunwai (IGRS) Portal: https://jansunwai.up.nic.in/
- UP Online RTI Portal: https://rtionline.up.gov.in/
- UP Online RTI Request Submission Page: https://rtionline.up.gov.in/request/request.php?lan=E


Facing a similar challenge? Share the details in the box below, and our team of experts will do their best to help.