Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI: Exposing ₹54.70 Crore Fraud and Statutory Delays

Digital governance in India promised a seamless bridge between citizens and state departments through online platforms. However, systemic failures frequently trap citizens in the Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI evasion cycle when requesting public records.

Specifically, portals like CPGRAMS often route complaints aimlessly instead of ensuring transparent, accountable outcomes.

A recent multi-state financial fraud exceeded ₹54.70 Crores.

Furthermore, it reached the Chief Minister Secretariat of Uttar Pradesh and the UPSIC.

Ultimately, this case illustrates how officials use arbitrary closures to dodge statutory accountability.

Indeed, this is not merely one citizen’s legal battle.

Instead, it serves as a textbook study of Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI failures in action.

Specifically, it reveals how authorities routinely bypass safeguards under the Right to Information Act, 2005.

Key Takeaways

  • Digital governance in India exposes citizens to issues with Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI when seeking public records.
  • A ₹54.70 crore fraud case highlights systemic failures and arbitrary closures by officials to evade accountability.
  • The investigation reveals jurisdictional lapses, leading to a cycle of misdirection without resolution.
  • Citizens faced delays and refusals under the Right to Information Act, prompting further appeals to address the obstructions.
  • Ending Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI delays is crucial to ensuring transparency and enforcing statutory timelines in public governance.

1. The Crisis: ₹54.70 Crore Identity Theft and Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI Issues

At the heart of this dispute lies a grave economic offence.

Specifically, under Case Crime No. 291/2023, fraudsters exploited an individual’s PAN identity.

In fact, perpetrators operated illicit bank accounts and shell business loops across state lines.

The local police tracked roughly ₹16.12 Crores.

However, Income Tax summaries revealed total exploitation crossing ₹54.70 Crores.

Despite the staggering scale, the local investigation hit a brick wall.

Specifically, central tax authorities failed to share critical banking documents with district police.

Consequently, the complainant recognized that district police lacked inter-state reach.

Therefore, they filed CPGRAMS Grievance No. DOPAT/E/2026/0009037 on 5 July 2026.

In doing so, they formally requested a investigation transfer to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI).

2. Jurisdictional Lapse: Initiating Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI Obstruction

Under the DSPE Act, 1946, specific authorities hold the power to refer cases to the CBI.

Specifically, this authority rests strictly with the State Government or a Constitutional Court.

As a result, a District Superintendent of Police has zero legal authority to decide on a CBI probe.

The Central Government grievance reached the Chief Minister Secretariat under IGRS No. 60000260179927.

However, the Secretariat routed the file straight down to the Superintendent of Police, Mirzapur.

Ironically, this action pushed the matter into a cycle of Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI misdirection.

Consequently, the inquiry report on 19 August 2026 candidly acknowledged the legal reality.

Namely, transferring an investigation to the CBI falls outside district police competence.

Therefore, the matter required resolution at the State Government level.

Logically, that admission should have triggered an escalation to the State Home Department.

Instead, on 19 August 2026, the Chief Minister Secretariat simply marked the grievance “Case Closed.”

3. Using Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI Requests to Expose Secretariat Decisions

Faced with arbitrary closure, the citizen turned to statutory remedies.

Accordingly, on 20 August 2026, they filed RTI Application No. DOCMO/R/2026/60959.

They submitted this request directly to the Public Information Officer of the Chief Minister Office.

Crucially, the application focused on internal decision-making processes.

Instead of targeting local police diaries, the seven points audited Secretariat actions directly:

  1. File missing details and authorization transferring the grievance to SP Mirzapur.
  2. Rules permitting a CBI-transfer request to be disposed of at the district level.
  3. Documentary evidence showing application of mind by Secretariat officials before closure.
  4. Record of communications sent back to DoPT regarding jurisdictional mismatch.
  5. Identity and reasoning of the officer who marked the file “Case Closed.”
  6. Established State procedure for processing CBI consent under the DSPE Act, 1946.
  7. Certified copies of all correspondence exchanged between the CM Secretariat and DoPT.

Every requested document resided exclusively in the custody of the State Secretariat.

4. Anatomy of Breakdown: Illegal Transfers in Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI Handling

What ensued over the next three months represents a series of statutory violations under the RTI Act, 2005:

  • Violation of Section 7(1) & 7(2): The statutory 30-day deadline expired on 19 September 2026. As a consequence, complete silence resulted in a deemed refusal.
  • Inaction at First Appeal Stage: The applicant filed First Appeal No. DOCMO/A/2026/60217 on 15 October 2026. However, the 30-day window elapsed without any speaking order.
  • Violation of Section 6(3): The PIO unilaterally transferred the application to SP Mirzapur on 3 November 2026, creating registration SPMZR/R/2026/80081.

Under Section 6(3), transfers are permissible only within 5 days of receipt.

Executing a transfer 75 days after filing while an appeal is pending remains ultra vires.

Even more glaring is the mala fide destination of the transfer.

In particular, routing questions about Secretariat file notings back to Mirzapur illustrates Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI evasion.

After all, SP Mirzapur does not maintain State Secretariat records.

5. Escalation to UPSIC: Challenging Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI Tactics

Left with no effective remedy, the citizen escalated the matter on 20 November 2026.

Specifically, they filed Second Appeal No. A-20261102399 before the UPSIC.

In essence, the appeal asks the Commission to address deliberate obstruction of information.

To that end, it requests five concrete statutory reliefs:

  • Quashing the illegal transfer dated 3 November 2026 under Section 6(3).
  • Directing the CMO PIO to furnish complete records free of charge under Section 7(6).
  • Imposing the maximum penalty of ₹25,000 under Section 20(1) for deemed refusal.
  • Recommending disciplinary action under Section 20(2) for persistent obstruction.
  • Awarding compensation under Section 19(8)(b) for harassment caused.

6. Why Ending Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI Delays Matters

The broader lesson of this episode remains unmistakable.

Across India, grievance portals suffer from a disposal-by-forwarding culture.

When citizens audit arbitrary closures, delayed transfers create a pattern of Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI evasion.

In truth, transparency laws only work when statutory timelines carry real consequences.

Otherwise, public information officers might ignore statutory duties without facing penalties.

Case A-20261102399 is coming up before the State Information Commission.

Ultimately, the outcome will show whether Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI tactics meet firm accountability.

This reference sheet consolidates all registration numbers and portal web links. Additionally, it includes official contact details of the concerned public authorities related to UPSIC Second Appeal No. A-20261102399 and RTI Application No. DOCMO/R/2026/60959.

1. Complete List of Application & Case IDs

Underlying Criminal Case: Initially, victims registered Case Crime No. 291/2023 at P.S. Kotwali Katra, Mirzapur, on 11 November 2023 under Section 420 IPC and Sections 66C & 66D of the IT Act. Currently, the Cyber Crime Police Station continues to investigate this matter. However, local progress stalled amidst systemic Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI delays.

CPGRAMS Grievance (Central Govt / DoPT AVD-II): Subsequently, the applicant submitted a formal request for a CBI investigation via CPGRAMS Grievance No. DOPAT/E/2026/0009037 on 5 July 2026. However, officials engaged in Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI tactics before closing the case on 19 August 2026.

UP IGRS / Jansunwai Reference: Meanwhile, the applicant filed UP IGRS Reference No. 60000260179927 on 22 July 2026. Subsequently, the Circle Officer (Operations), Mirzapur, submitted an inquiry report (AIGRAS-08/2026) on 19 August 2026. Specifically, this report revealed how local officials engaged in Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI shifts.

Original RTI Application u/s 6(1): Following the grievance closure, RTI Application No. DOCMO/R/2026/60959 (Txn ID: DOCMOR20260000001133) was filed on 20 August 2026. As a result of non-response, it entered deemed refusal after 19 September 2026. Eventually, delayed transfers further highlighted ongoing Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI evasions.

First Appeal u/s 19(1): Because of the deemed refusal, the applicant lodged First Appeal No. DOCMO/A/2026/60217 on 15 October 2026. Although authorities requested PIO comments, classic Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI stalls prevented a final order.

Transferred RTI Application (SP Mirzapur): Furthermore, the transferred application was re-registered under No. SPMZR/R/2026/80081 on 3 November 2026. However, this illegal transfer illustrates deeper Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI structural issues under Section 6(3).

UPSIC Second Appeal u/s 19(3): Finally, the applicant filed Second Appeal No. A-20261102399 (Applicant ID: UPICR20240000149) on 20 November 2026 before the Uttar Pradesh State Information Commission. In doing so, they sought to halt Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI delays during their online hearing.

2. Contact Details of Concerned Public Authorities & Officers

A. Chief Minister Office / Secretariat, Government of Uttar Pradesh

Official Address: Lok Bhawan / Uttar Pradesh Secretariat, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh – 226001. This office manages appeals regarding Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI disputes.

To begin with, the First Appellate Authority (FAA) for the Chief Minister Office is Shri Ram Gopal Singh, Deputy Secretary (L.S. Sec-1). Specifically, he can be reached via mobile at 9454413718 or by email at ram.13718@gov.in.

Meanwhile, the Concerned PIO handling RTI Application No. DOCMO/R/2026/60959 is Smt. Manju Verma, Section Officer (L.S. Sec-4). Her contact mobile is 9454419907 (Office: 0522-2226342). Additionally, her official email ID is manju.19907@gov.in.

Additionally, the PIO listed on the First Appeal form is Shri Pradeep Kumar, Section Officer (L.S. Sec-1). He can be contacted at 945441XXXX (masked on portal; Office: 0522-2226457). Alternatively, he can be reached via email at pradip.11743@gov.in.

Furthermore, the Nodal Officer of the RTI Cell is Shri Manish Singh, Section Officer. His mobile contact is 9554417327 (Office: 0522-2226455). In addition, his email address is manish.21320@gov.in.

Finally, the CPGRAMS / IGRS Officer at the CM Secretariat is Shri Bhaskar Chandra Kandpal, Joint Secretary (Room No. 321). He can be reached by phone at 0522-2226350 or email at bhaskar.31532@gov.in. Additionally, the Jansunwai WIM is jansunwai-up@gov.in.

B. District Police Administration, Mirzapur

Official Address: Office of the Superintendent of Police, Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh – 231001. Local officers receive transferred Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI files here.

Regarding the District Police Administration in Mirzapur, the Transferee Public Authority for transferred application SPMZR/R/2026/80081 is the Superintendent of Police (SP), Mirzapur. The office can be contacted via CUG mobile at 9454400299 or by email at spmzr-up@nic.in.

In addition, the IGRS Inquiry Officer for Reference No. 60000260179927 is Mohd. Fahim, Circle Officer (Operations), Mirzapur. Specifically, he can be reached at mobile 9454401594 (via SP Office, Mirzapur).

C. UP Online RTI Portal Technical Helpdesk

  • Telephone: 0522-7118629 (10:00 AM – 05:00 PM on working days). Citizens report portal errors and Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI glitches here.
  • Email: onlinertihelpline.up@gov.in (For portal technical queries only)
Public Authority / PortalOfficial Web LinkPrimary Purpose
Uttar Pradesh RTI Online Portalhttps://rtionline.up.gov.in/Track DOCMO/R/2026/60959, DOCMO/A/2026/60217, and SPMZR/R/2026/80081
Uttar Pradesh State Information Commission (UPSIC)https://upsic.up.gov.in/Track Second Appeal A-20261102399, cause lists, and online hearing notices
CPGRAMS Portal (Central Government)https://pgportal.gov.in/Track Central Government Grievance DOPAT/E/2026/0009037
Department of Personnel & Training (DoPT), Govt. of Indiahttps://dopt.gov.in/Central authority overseeing AVD-II, CBI administration, and RTI policy
Chief Minister Office, Uttar Pradeshhttps://upcmo.up.nic.in/Official portal of the Chief Minister Secretariat, Lucknow
UP Jansunwai – Samadhan (IGRS Portal)https://jansunwai.up.nic.in/Track UP IGRS Reference 60000260179927
Uttar Pradesh Policehttps://uppolice.gov.in/Official UP Police portal & Mirzapur district police directory
Home » Bureaucratic Ping-Pong & RTI in India Explained

Facing a similar challenge? Share the details in the box below, and our team of experts will do their best to help.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
  1. This matter concerns with the corruption in the ujjwala scheme of the prime Minister why department of petroleum and natural…