Who committed the contempt , 20 judges against whom allegations were made or whistle blower?

Justice
Karnan’s letter went on to state: “I have given a recent allegation that there
were 20 corrupt judges in the Madras High Court and the Hon’ble Justice S
Kishan Kaul is No. 1 accused.Even this accusation was ignored although my
complaint is still on file. It is observed that the 7 judges mentioned above
are all out for a contempt case against me, presumably to clear the path for
Justice Mr. S K Kaul’s elevation (to the Supreme Court).”During a phone
conversation , “he is facing financial constraints because of which he is
not able to travel to Delhi and hire a high-profile lawyer”.
12
February 2017
10:59
Karnan, who was
appointed to the Madras HC in 2009.
The courts
have “no power to enforce punishment against a sitting Judge of the High
Court”, Justice CS Karnan has said in response to a contempt notice by the
Supreme Court for approaching the Prime Minister with a list of judges he
considers corrupt.
Undoubtedly
made allegations subject to enquiry in order to trace the truth and premature
action in order to shut the mouth is violation of freedom of expression.
On
February 8, a seven-judge Supreme Court bench headed by Chief Justice JS Khehar
had ordered the registrar general of the Calcutta HC to relieve Karnan of his
duties. Justice Karnan was also asked to appear before the bench on February 13
to face contempt charges.
Procedure
for Removal of Judges
 A resolution must be passed by the both house
by the majority of total members of the house &
 By the majority of two-third of members
of  both the house present and voting.
 Passed resolution must present before the
President of Indian in the same session
 And that must signed by the President of
India.
In a
letter to the registrar general of the Supreme Court on Friday, a copy of which
is available with HT, Karnan wrote: “This said order does not conform to logic,
therefore is not suitable for execution. The characteristic of this order
clearly shows the upper caste judges are taking law into their hands and
misusing their judicial power by operating the same against a SC/ST Judge with
mala fide intention of getting rid of him. Therefore, the suo motu contempt
order dated 08.02.2017 is not sustainable under law.”
He also
pointed to the instance from last year where he attempted to file a case
against Chief Justice JS Khehar under the SC/ST Act and requested that the
contempt case against him be heard after Khehar retired.
Justice Karnan has
invoked his identity as a Dalit at a time when there isn’t a single judge from
the SC or ST communities in the Supreme Court. The last Dalit Supreme Court
judge was former Chief Justice KG Balakrishnan, who retired on May 11, 2010.
Justice
Karnan’s letter went on to state: “I have given a recent allegation that there
were 20 corrupt judges in the Madras High Court and the Hon’ble Justice S
Kishan Kaul is No. 1 accused. Even this accusation was ignored although my
complaint is still on file. It is observed that the 7 judges mentioned above
are all out for a contempt case against me, presumably to clear the path for
Justice Mr. S K Kaul’s elevation (to the Supreme Court).”
“The Suo
Motu contempt order against me a Dalit judge and restraining my judicial and
administrative assignment is unethical and goes against the SC/ST Atrocities
Act. It is certainly a national issue and a wise decision would be to refer the
issue to the House of Parliament.”
Confirming the
authenticity of the letter, Karnan told HT over phone from Kolkata, “Yes, it is
true that the letter was written by me. And I don’t think there is anything
more to elaborate on the matter right now.”
When requested for
an interview, the judge who is set to retire in a few months, said, “I shall
speak my mind very soon. I will answer all questions.”
Karnan has gone incommunicado after his defiant letter.
“He has isolated himself from the outside world and is refusing to meet
anybody,” Supreme Court lawyer Mathews Nedumpara told HT. Nedumpara, who is the
president of the National Lawyers’ Campaign for Judicial Transparency, said a
delegation from his organisation had been trying without success to meet Karnan
since the contempt order was issued.

Nedumpara said,
“Justice Karnan has been discriminated against and socially isolated by the
legal fraternity. This has sent him into extreme depression. During a phone
conversation with me he also said that he is facing
financial constraints because of which he is not able to travel to Delhi and
hire a high-profile lawyer.
We offered to represent him pro bono but he
refused.”

3 comments on Who committed the contempt , 20 judges against whom allegations were made or whistle blower?

  1. Justice Karnan’s letter went on to state: “I have given a recent allegation that there were 20 corrupt judges in the Madras High Court and the Hon’ble Justice S Kishan Kaul is No. 1 accused.Even this accusation was ignored although my complaint is still on file. It is observed that the 7 judges mentioned above are all out for a contempt case against me, presumably to clear the path for Justice Mr. S K Kaul’s elevation (to the Supreme Court).”During a phone conversation , "he is facing financial constraints because of which he is not able to travel to Delhi and hire a high-profile lawyer".

  2. Justice Karnan made allegations against few judges who are indulged in the corruption but apex court instead of taking seriously the representation issued notice against whistle blower judge. According to Justice Karnan's letter, his economy is too much poor so he can't afford a lawyer. Undoubtedly this country is in stranglehold of corruption.

  3. मोदी सर लगभग साल बीतने वाला है मोहम्मद अकरम के के लिए CRPF को हमने फीस पे किया एक ही प्रार्थनापत्र के लिए उपरोक्त रिक्रूटिंग एजेंसी ने दो बार फीस लिए एक बार का फीस वापस करने के लिए लगभग दो सौ पत्र दिए आपको किन्तु आज तक ज्यादा ली गई फीस वापस नही की गयी और आप कहते है आप के यहा भ्रस्टाचार नही है |
    आपके यहा चपरासी ४००००.०० रुपये पर मंथ पाता है लेकिन देश की आधी आबादी भुखमरी के कगार पर है आप को सिर्फ चपरासी दिखाई पड़ता है और जो परिवार रोज भूख की वजह से मरते वे आप को दिखाई नही पड़ते जब की समाचार पत्रों की सुर्खियाँ बनती है अक्सर भूख से हुई मौते |
    मोदी सर मंरेगा जाँच का आदेश केन्द्रीय जांच ब्यूरो द्वारा माननीय उच्च न्यायालय द्वारा कांग्रेस के समय में ही हुआ था उस समय चार महीने में मिर्ज़ापुर जनपद में उपरोक्त जांच एजेंसी की टीम आठ बार आई थी किन्तु आप जब से सत्ता में है एक भी बार नही आई और आप का कार्यकाल ढाई साल बीत गया और अब टीम आई जब विधान सभा इलेक्शन का नोटीफीकेशन जारी हुआ | इससे स्पस्ट है की आप की सरकार कांग्रेस से ज्यादा ईमानदार है कांग्रेस के समय में केंद्रीय मंत्री जेल जाता था आप के समय में चपरासी भी जेल नही जाता |
    श्री मान जी कोई ऐसा कार्यालय नही है जहा घुस न माँगा जाता हो पेशी तो जबरदस्ती ली जाती है प्रार्थी खुद इसका भुक्तभोगी है आप दस रुपये के नोट दिलवा दे हर बार पेशी में दे कर ख़त्म हो जाएगा और हम बिना दिए लौटे तो बुला के लेंगे | पहले दो रुपये लेते थे फिर पांच रुपये अब दस रुपये लेते है हास्यास्पद बात यह है की अधिकारी और मजिस्ट्रेट वही बगल में बैठे रहते है | भ्रस्टाचार वेतन बढ़ाने से नही घटेगा बल्कि इमानदारी को प्रमोट करने से बढ़ेगा |
    श्री मान जी आपने अपने ढाई साल के कार्यकाल में लोकपाल की नियुक्ति को अमर्यादित तरीके से रोक रखा है और हर देशवासी इसको समझता है यहा पर भी आप संबिधान के उपबंधो की रक्षा की क्यों की कांग्रेस तो उसी समय लोकपाल ला रही थी किन्तु आप मजबूत लोकपाल हम लोगो को देंना चाहते है जो की भ्रस्टाचार को समूल नष्ट कर देगा किन्तु ऐसा लगता है की मजबूत लोकपाल के लिए यह पांच वर्ष पर्याप्त नही है देश की जनता को पांच वर्ष का समय और देना होगा |
    पारदर्शिता और जवाबदेही के लिए जनसूचना अधिकार २००५ कांग्रेस द्वारा लाया गया किन्तु उसे भी प्रभावहीन बना दिया गया न्यायालय तो पहले ही जनसूचना अधिकार के तहत सूचनाए देने से परहेज करते थे और अब ब्यूरोक्रेसी भी नही देना चाहती | केन्द्रीय सूचना आयोग और राज्य सूचना आयोग महज आदेश पारित करते है उन आदेशो का कोई असर नही होता है |

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: