R.T.I. Applications are transferred from one office to other but no information is made available.

Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com>
How much surprising that in the department of income tax, government of India R.T.I. Applications are transferred from one office to other but no information is made available.
1 message
Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com> 21 June 2017 at 16:08
To: pmosb <pmosb@pmo.nic.in>, presidentofindia@rb.nic.in, urgent-action <urgent-action@ohchr.org>, supremecourt <supremecourt@nic.in>, cmup <cmup@up.nic.in>

An appeal under subsection 1 of section 19 of Right to Information Act 2005.
To
                                              First appellate authority/ Joint
                                               commissioner income tax ,Range-III
                                                     Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh, India
Subject-In regard to communication F.No.ITO 3(2)/MZP/RTI/2017-15/69 dated:18/05/2017 by CPIO ,Ward-III(2), Mirzapur as denied sought information in cryptic style by making mockery of provisions of Right to Information Act 2005.
Information sought as-Hon’ble CPIO may provide following information.
1-Please make available GO/CIRCULAR /ACT WHICH allows transaction on a slip.
2-Whether Rs.10000.00 is taken on slip without providing any description of charges. Please made available provision of law allows such cryptic dealings.
3-Please made available information when more 5000.00 deposited, then also transaction was made on slip .IT Mirzapur considers it legitimate. Please make available GO/CIRCULAR.
4-When rest of six thousand paid, then slip was taken and patient was discharged and no receipt was given. Being top monitoring body, please provide the provision of law which allows such cryptic practice.
5-Matter concerned with  Commissioner of Income Tax , Officer name-GEET MALA MOHANANEY but department procrastinated by sending RTI Communiqué to various public authorities. Please explain the cause of procrastination.
Aforementioned sought information under five points denied by CPIO ,Ward-III(2),Mirzapur as follows.
1-Information sought doesn’t pertain to this office.
2-Information sought doesn’t pertain to this office.
3-Action/inquiry has been made as par Income Tax Act 1961.
4- Information sought doesn’t pertain to this office.
5-Matter is being received being jurisdictional Assessing Officer as per prevalent practices.
For details, take the perusal of copy of communication sent to your appellant by CPIO, Ward-III(2),Mirzapur attached with this appeal.
Short submissions of your appellant are as follows.
1-Right to Information Act 2005 was brought up by government of India to enhance transparency and accountability in the working of public authority.
2-Under point 1,2 and 4, CPIO ,Ward-III(2),Mirzapur affirmed as – Information sought doesn’t pertain to this office but at the same instant of time ,he has forgotten his duty as prescribed under subsection 3 of section 6 of Right to Information Act 2005 that if sought information is not concerned with the public authority ,then it will transfer the R.T.I. communiqué to public authority concerned within one week from the date of receipt of the R.T.I. communiqué. Consequently CPIO ,Ward-III(2),Mirzapur violated aforementioned provision of transparency act.
3-Under point -3, CPIO, Ward-III(2),Mirzapur affirmed as – Action/inquiry has been made as par Income Tax Act 1961 but your appellant sought information as- Please made available information when more 5000.00 deposited, then also transaction was made on slip .IT Mirzapur considers it legitimate. Please make available GO/CIRCULAR. It is unfortunate that nowhere provisions of aforementioned act i.e. Income Tax Act 1961 allows transaction on a slip. Consequently CPIO, Ward-III (2), Mirzapur made available a misleading information regarding this point.
4- Under point -5, CPIO, Ward-III (2), Mirzapur affirmed as Matter is being received being jurisdictional Assessing Officer as per prevalent practices  but your appellant sought information as- Matter is concerned with  Commissioner of Income Tax , Officer name-GEET MALA MOHANANEY but department procrastinated by sending RTI Communiqué to various public authorities. Please explain the cause of procrastination. It is most unfortunate that instead of such procrastination, in order to fix accountability of GEET MALA MOHANANEY, this R.T.I. communiqué be transferred to CPIO of Geet Mala Mohananey so that cause of procrastination available in office be made available to your appellant.  
                        This is humble request of your appellant that CPIO may be directed to take actions in accordance with the provisions of Right to Information Act 2005 so that sought information be accessible to your appellant. Accountability of CPIO, Ward-III(2),Mirzapur may also be fixed for adopting lackadaisical approach in dealing with R.T.I. communiqué.  For this your appellant shall ever pray you Hon’ble Sir.
                                                                   Yours sincerely
Date-28/05/2017               Yogi M. P. Singh, Mobile number-7379105911, Mohalla- Surekapuram, Jabalpur Road, District-Mirzapur , Uttar Pradesh. Pin code-231001.


4 attachments
img076.jpg
540K
img077.jpg
1241K
img078.jpg
738K
First appeal before joint commissioner income tax ,Range-III.pdf
499K

2 comments on R.T.I. Applications are transferred from one office to other but no information is made available.

  1. Under point -5, CPIO, Ward-III (2), Mirzapur affirmed as Matter is being received being jurisdictional Assessing Officer as per prevalent practices but your appellant sought information as- Matter is concerned with Commissioner of Income Tax , Officer name-GEET MALA MOHANANEY but department procrastinated by sending RTI Communiqué to various public authorities. Please explain the cause of procrastination. It is most unfortunate that instead of such procrastination, in order to fix accountability of GEET MALA MOHANANEY, this R.T.I. communiqué be transferred to CPIO of Geet Mala Mohananey so that cause of procrastination available in office be made available to your appellant.

  2. Under point -3, CPIO, Ward-III(2),Mirzapur affirmed as – Action/inquiry has been made as par Income Tax Act 1961 but your appellant sought information as- Please made available information when more 5000.00 deposited, then also transaction was made on slip .IT Mirzapur considers it legitimate. Please make available GO/CIRCULAR. It is unfortunate that nowhere provisions of aforementioned act i.e. Income Tax Act 1961 allows transaction on a slip. Consequently CPIO, Ward-III (2), Mirzapur made available a misleading information regarding this point.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: