More than one year passed ,but no wrongdoer was sent behind the bar by C.B.I.

Order of Lucknow bench of High court of
Judicature at Allahabad passed on 31-Jan-2014 ,concerned with C.B.I. Enquiry in
the anomaly and siphoning of public fund under MGNREGA scheme in Uttar Pradesh.
Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P
Singh 
<yogimpsingh@gmail.com>
12:00 AM (7 minutes ago)
to pmosb, supremecourt, urgent-action, cenvigil, cmup, hgovup, csup
Whether this order was passed for only Haliya block
of Mirzapur district.
With due respect your applicant wants to draw
the kind attention of the Hon’ble Sir to the following submissions as follows.
1-It is submitted before the
Hon’ble Sir that 
whether this order which
was passed on 31-Jan-2014 was merely to carry out enquiry in Haliya block of
Mirzapur district.
 Hon’ble Sir please
take the perusal of excellent order of Hon’ble judges of Hon’ble High court-
In view of above, we allow the writ petition with
following order : 
(I) A writ in the nature of mandamus
is issued directing the Central Bureau of Investigation to investigate the
abuse and misappropriation of fund as well as the abuse of power under
 Mahatma Gandhi National
Rural Guarantee Scheme with regard to seven districts of State of U.P, namely
Balrampur, Gonda, Mahoba, Sonbhadra, Sant Kabir Nagar, 
Mirzapur and Kushinagar
in the years 2007 to 2010 
with appropriate
action and prosecution in accordance with law
. 
(II) A further writ in the nature of mandamus is
issued directing the Central Bureau of Investigation to hold a preliminary
enquiry under Chapter IX of CBI Manual with regard to other districts of the
State of U.P for the aforesaid three years relating to abuse, misuse or
misappropriation of fund provided by the Government of India under Mahatma
Gandhi National Rural Guarantee Scheme(supra) with follow-up regular enquiry,
if required. 
(III) The State Government is
further directed to provide all necessary assistance including manpower to CBI
within a month from the date of receipt of request to proceed for investigation
in pursuance to the present judgment.
 
(IV) A writ in the nature of mandamus is issued
directing the State Government to consider for establishment of multi-member
State Quality Monitor at district and State level to supervise unitilisation of
fund under Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Guarantee Scheme till the Government
of India frames appropriate rules, regulations or issue appropriate order
keeping in view the observation made in the body of judgment. 
The CBI shall submit status report
to this Court at the interval of every three months with regard to
investigation done in pursuance to the present judgment.
 
The writ petition is allowed accordingly. No order
as to costs. 
Since it is a final judgment, Registry shall ensure
to list the writ petition before the present Bench to monitor the compliance of
the judgment. 
Let a copy of the judgment be sent to the Chief
Secretary, Government of U.P., Principal Secretary, Home, Government of U.P.,
Secretary, Ministry of Law & Justice, Government of India, Director,
C.B.I., New Delhi for compliance and appropriate action in pursuance to the
observation made in the body of the judgment. 
(Justice Ashok Pal Singh) (Justice Devi Prasad
Singh) 
January 31, 2014 
Let a certified copy of the present judgment be
issued as per rules to the parties’ counsel as well as Mr. Bireshwar Nath,
learned counsel for C.B.I. within three days. 
(Justice Ashok Pal Singh) (Justice Devi Prasad
Singh) 
January 31, 2014 
2-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that
Hon’ble Sir may be pleased to take a glance of following representation sent to
various public authorities.
Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P
Singh 
<yogimpsingh@gmail.com>
3:01 PM (4 minutes ago)
to cenvigil
http://yogimpsingh.blogspot.com/2015/01/why-government-staffs-dont-see-rampant.htmlMahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com>
1:53 PM (0 minutes ago)
to pmosb, supremecourt, hgovup, cmup
Hon’ble Sir-With due respect your applicant
wants to draw kind attention of the Hon’ble Sir to the following submissions as
follows.
1-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir
that villagers of village panchayat- Nibee Gaharwar ,Block-Chhanbey
,District-Mirzapur ,State-Uttar Pradesh submitted representation addressed to
D.M. Mirzapur dated- 30.5.2014 alleging large scale irregularity in MGNREGA
scheme and demanded stern action against wrongdoers. The scan copy of aforesaid
representation is attached with this e-mail.
2-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that
If Hon’ble Sir will see the attached photo
,then in this photo a new designed house is made and before the house a new
tractor with trolly is parked belong to Ramesh Chandra Dubey S/O Gaja Nand
Dubey who is the MGNREGA worker whose name was deleted because of fear of CBI
enquiry and family members of gram pradhan also deleted . Latest forming land
of one million approximate was purchased by by Ramesh Chandra Dubey and his
elder brother as family consist of two brothers.
3-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that
Grievance Description : With due respect your
applicant wants to draw the kind attention of the Hon’ble Sir to the following
submissions as follows-1-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that MGNREGA
job card holder Gulab UP-62-001-022-001/136 , account number 19386 ,district
cooperative bank, Pintu UP-62-001-022-001/137 ,account number 19384 , district
cooperative bank and Ghanshyam UP-62-001-022-001/139 ,account number nill I.e.
no bank or post office account were registered as MGNREGA worker on 12/4/2006 ,
12/4/2006 and 12/4/2006 by concealing its title Dubey as all are Dubey. There
are family members of gram pradhan Santosh Dhar Dubey village
panchayat-Nibigaharwar Block-Chhanbey District-Mirzapur State-Uttar Pradesh and
are landlords and itself hire workers for farming . 2-It is submitted before
the Hon’ble Sir that Whether an individual working at seven hundred kilometer
away from the village panchayat, how can work as MGNREGA worker? Whether it is
justified that those entitled for job under MGNREGA may be deprived from this
opportunity arbitrarily . 3- It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that
Whether material supplier under MGNREGA may be MGNREGA worker as being done by
gram pradhan Santosh Dhar Dubey and secretary of the village panchayat. From
the working style of District level officers ,every thing is possible for the
gram pradhan. Whether Government officers ever take the perusal of provision of
MGNREGA. There is sheer irregularity in the implementation of the act.
MGNREGA job card
holder
 Gulab UP-62-001-022-001/136 , account number 19386 ,district
cooperative bank
Pintu UP-62-001-022-001/137 ,account
number 19384 , district cooperative bank and Ghanshyam UP-62-001-022-001/139
,account number nill I.e. no bank or post office  account were
registered as MGNREGA worker on 12/4/2006 , 12/4/2006 and 12/4/2006 by
concealing its title Dubey as all are Dubey. These are family members of gram
pradhan Santosh Dhar Dubey village panchayat-Nibigaharwar Block-Chhanbey
District-Mirzapur State-Uttar Pradesh  and are
landlords  and itself hire workers for farming .
It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir
that Gulab Dubey S/O Abhaynath Dubey is material supplier under MGNREGA as
obvious from the attachment. Whether it is precondition that material supplier
under MGNREGA be the close relative of Gram Pradhan and MGNREGA job holder. It
seems that MGNREGA scheme of Government is the excellent source of income for
the relatives of Gram Pradhan.
                                               This
is humble request of your applicant to you Hon’ble Sir to take steps against
wrongdoers so that public confidence may be built up  in the government
machinery. For this your applicant shall ever pray you Hon’ble Sir.
                                                     
Yours sincerely
                                                   
Yogi M. P. Singh
Mohalla-Surekapuram , Jabalpur Road ,
District-Mirzapur , State-Uttar Pradesh , India
3-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that
more than one year passed since the order was passed by Hon’ble Judges but
whenever C.B.I. Comes in the district first it halts in the district under the
hospitality of district administration and then it moves towards Haliya block.
EOW agency of state government did better job in less time but the fault was
that sanction was not granted by state functionaries at that time. Hon’ble
please take a glance of following stories. If needed more stories will be made
available.
                                                          
This is humble request of your applicant to you
Hon’ble Sir that It can never be justified to overlook  the rights of
citizenry by delivering services in arbitrary manner by floating all set up
norms. This is sheer mismanagement which is encouraging wrongdoers to reap
benefit of loopholes in system and depriving poor citizens from right to
justice. Therefore it is need of hour to take concrete steps in order to curb
grown anarchy in the system. For this your applicant shall ever pray you
Hon’ble Sir.
           
               ‘Yours  sincerely
           
                Yogi M. P. Singh
Mohalla-Surekapuram, Jabalpur Road
District-Mirzapur , Uttar Pradesh ,India .
2 Attachments

2 comments on More than one year passed ,but no wrongdoer was sent behind the bar by C.B.I.

  1. (I) A writ in the nature of mandamus is issued directing the Central Bureau of Investigation to investigate the abuse and misappropriation of fund as well as the abuse of power under Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Guarantee Scheme with regard to seven districts of State of U.P, namely Balrampur, Gonda, Mahoba, Sonbhadra, Sant Kabir Nagar, Mirzapur and Kushinagar in the years 2007 to 2010 with appropriate action and prosecution in accordance with law.
    (II) A further writ in the nature of mandamus is issued directing the Central Bureau of Investigation to hold a preliminary enquiry under Chapter IX of CBI Manual with regard to other districts of the State of U.P for the aforesaid three years relating to abuse, misuse or misappropriation of fund provided by the Government of India under Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Guarantee Scheme(supra) with follow-up regular enquiry, if required.

  2. If the premier investigating agency will be proved to be teethless ,then what other can be expected ? As far as my knowledge is concerned, C.B.I. only sticked to Haliya block of MiRZAPUR district. More than one year passed but no wrongdoer was sent behind the bar is showing that there is laxity on the part of C.B.I.. How many years will be taken to complete the enquiry ? Whether wrongdoers will be punished can be easily guessed. Whether such practice can provide justice to poor and downtrodden section.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: