Lack of transparency in income tax department itself proved by its staffs which is root cause of slip culture

Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com>
Why there is no transparency and accountability in the working of the department of income tax ,Government of India.
Mahesh Pratap Singh Yogi M P Singh <yogimpsingh@gmail.com> 1 April 2017 at 20:47
To: presidentofindia@rb.nic.in, pmosb <pmosb@pmo.nic.in>, urgent-action <urgent-action@ohchr.org>,
supremecourt <supremecourt@nic.in>, cvc@nic.in, ccit.lucknow@incometax.gov.in, hobaclko@cbi.gov.in

Whether this is not mockery of Right to Information Act 2005. The 
working style in which concerned staffs, Department of Income Tax 
of government of India overlooked the matter of public interest and 
concealed the cryptic dealing by overlooking contents of the
 submitted grievance is not reflection of rampant corruption in the 
system. Whether public staffs are not acting caucus with their private
 partners in order to promote wrongdoings causing great damage to 
public treasury for individual gains. 
01 April 2017
18:46
With due respect your applicant wants to draw the kind attention of the Hon’ble Sir
 to the following submissions as follows.
1-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that why
Forwarded to-Commissioner of Income Tax , Officer name-GEET MALA MOHANANEY , Officer 
Designation-
Pr.CIT Contact Address Aayakar Bhawan
38, M.G. Road, Civil Lines, Allahabad 211001
Status as on 18 Dec 2016 was substituted by
Forwarded to
:
Central Board of Direct Taxes (Income Tax)
Contact Address
:
D/o Revenue,Room No. 255,
CBDT (HQ),North Block
New Delhi110001 after submission of R.T.I. Communique.
 Whether it is not cryptic dealing.
Grievance Status
Thank You for Your Valuable Feedback
Registration Number
:
CBODT/E/2016/12369
Name Of Complainant
:
Yogi M P SINGH
Date of Receipt
:
13 Sep 2016
Received by
:
Central Board of Direct Taxes (Income Tax)
Forwarded to
:
Central Board of Direct Taxes (Income Tax)
Contact Address
:
D/o Revenue,Room No. 255,
CBDT (HQ),North Block
New Delhi110001
Contact Number
:
23095452
Grievance Description
:
In a simple delivery case erring clinic took Rs.21000.00 on slip bearing 
no address or any authentication. CMO Chauurasia and principal 
secretary has the rate list but don’t want to make public . Think about
 the gravity of situation that private clinic run by famous lady doctor in 
the district Mirzapur Uttar Pradesh made the bill Rs/21000.00 on a slip 
out of which 10000.00 taken in advance and Rs.5000.00 on
 11/09/2016 as obvious from the slip provided by the staffs of
 nursing home on 12/09/2016. 13 September 2016 15:42 
Hon’ble Prime Minister Sir whether C.B.D.T. AND its sister 
departments which come under the ambit of ministry of 
finance which is subordinate ministry comes under direct supervision
 of PMO is too much busy in sending the messages to unemployed 
youths and students who are PAN Card holders by confining to its 
offices instead of searching the tax evasions really taking place at 
large scale in the country. With due respect your applicant wants 
to draw the kind attention of the Hon’ble Sir to the following submissions as follows. 1-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that your applicant wants that public functionaries may ensure the rate list of services provided by private clinic and nursing homes on the gate of nursing homes which may easily accessible to the patients and his family members and relatives. Your applicant made numerous representations in this regard which are languishing in the various offices of the government of Uttar Pradesh awaiting action but concerned are only procrastinating in the matter concerned ipsofacto obvious from the attached documents with this representation. 2-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that whether good governance means few people may amass huge wealth while most may die of hunger and poverty. Whether government will tax those people who are deprived from two square meal and those amassing huge wealth will take coffee and tea with the public functionaries. 3-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that how much surprising that those must be subjected to pay taxes are allowed to run their businesses without imposing any set up norms and regulation while who some how arrange two square meal are subjected to extreme mental and physical torture. Simply in a delivery case ,family members has to deposit Rs.21000.00 merely on slip and no authenticated documents are made available to family members of the patient. Whether this is good governance, then what is anarchy? This is humble request of your applicant to you Hon’ble Sir that It can never be justified to overlook the rights of citizenry by delivering services in arbitrary manner by floating all set up norms. This is sheer mismanagement which is encouraging wrongdoers to reap benefit of loopholes in system and depriving poor citizens from right to justice. Therefore it is need of hour to take concrete steps in order to curb grown anarchy in the system. For this your applicant shall ever pray you Hon’ble Sir. ‘Yours sincerely Yogi M. P. Singh Mobile number-7379105911 Mohalla-Surekapuram, Jabalpur Road District-Mirzapur , Uttar Pradesh ,India .
Current Status
:
CASE CLOSED
Your Feedback
:
Poor
Date of Action
:
23 Dec 2016
Details
:
YOUR SUGGESTION HAS ALREADY BEEN FORWARDED TO THE CONCERNED OFFICE JURISDICTION I.E. JOINT COMMISSIONER, RANGE-3, MIRZAPUR FOR INFORMATION AND NECESSARY ACTION. Why the grievance was closed instead of redressing it? It is quite obvious that honest Modi government at centre is not interested to end the slip culture.
Status as on 01 Apr 2017
2-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that following 
R.T.I. Communique was submitted on 18-Dec-2016 sought information 
under following four points.
Online RTI Request Form Details 
RTI Request Details :-
RTI Request Registration number
DGICI/R/2016/50526
Public Authority
Directorate General of Income Tax (Intelligence &
 Criminal Investigations)
Personal Details of RTI Applicant:-
Name
Mahesh Pratap Singh
Gender
Male
Address
Mohalla Surekapuram , Jabalpur Road , District Mirzapur
Pincode
231001
Country
India
State
Uttar Pradesh
Status
Urban
Educational Status
Literate
Above Graduate
Phone Number
Details not provided
Mobile Number
+91-7379105911
Email-ID
yogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com
Request Details :-
Citizenship
Indian
Is the Requester Below Poverty Line ?
No
(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)
Description of Information Sought
An application under subsection 1 of section 6 of Right to Information Act 2005.
18 December 2016
11:56
With due respect your applicant is seeking following information in regard to grievance submitted on public grievance portal of government of India as follows. 
Grievance Status Registration Number- CBODT/E/2016/12369 Name Of Complainant-
Yogi M P SINGH , Date of Receipt- 13 Sep 2016 , Received by – Central Board of Direct Taxes (Income Tax)
Forwarded to-Commissioner of Income Tax , Officer name-GEET MALA MOHANANEY , Officer Designation-
Pr.CIT Contact Address Aayakar Bhawan
38, M.G. Road, Civil Lines, Allahabad 211001
Status as on 18 Dec 2016
Sought information -1-Please made available details of action taken on aforementioned grievance by the concerned staffs of public authorities. 
Sought information -2-Please made available the maximum duration taken by the department to redress the grievances by the citizenry. 
Sought information -3-Please made available the copy of report which was made available by the Commissioner of Income Tax ALLAHABAD to Central Board of Direct Taxes (Income Tax).
Sought information -4-Please made available name and designation of staff dealing with aforementioned grievance in the office of income tax department 
Aayakar Bhawan 38, M.G. Road, Civil Lines, Allahabad 211001 .
Please made available aforesaid sought information within stipulated time as prescribed under subsection 1 of section 7 of Right to Information Act 2005
Concerned CPIO
Nodal Officer
Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB)
3-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that following incomplete misleading information by CPIO after undue delay made available today as-
                                                         GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
                                           INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT, MIRZAPUR
F.No.ITO 3(2)/MZP/RTl/2O16-17/1719                                                    Date : 29.03.2017
From.
CPIO
Income Tax Officer.
Ward 3(2). Mirzapur.
To.
Sri Mahesh Pratap Singh
Yogi M. P. SIngh
MohllaIIa-Surekapuram
Jabalpur, Road. Mirzapur.
Sub: e-RTI application. Registration No.DGICI/R/2016/50525 dt 18.12.2016. under section 6(3) of
RT1 Act. 200$ of Shree Mahesh Pratap Singh, Yogi M.P. Singh. MohaIla-Surekapuram. Jabalpur
Road District- Mirzapur -reply regarding.
Please refer to the above mentioned subject,
In this connection, the information sought by you Is as under:-
1. An enquiry was made by the inspector of this office regarding your grievance. As per report of ITI  of
this office, the Dr. Meena Vishwakarma is regular tax Payer and files her income tax return on regular
basis, According to the doctor, the final bill has not been issued in your case because payment of
Rs. 6,000/- has still not been made.
2. Information sought for is available in public domain.
3. Information sought for does not pertain to this office.
4. information sought for does not pertain to this office,
The above information Is made available to you. If you are not satisfied with the above, you can appeal
to the first appellate authority I.e. Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Range-III, Mirzapur within 30 days.
                                                                                               Yours faithfully.
                                                                                              Income Tax Officer
                                                                                             Ward-3(2). Mkzapur.
Copy to. The Joint Commissioner of Income tax. RangeIII, MirzapuR for information
                                                                                            Income Tax Officer
                                                                                             Ward.3(2). Marzapur.
It is quite obvious that point 2,3 and 4 still untouched through a cryptic dealing not in public interest and interest of this country.
4-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that whether following information can provided by the concerned ministry. If made available information under point 1 may be set as precedent ,then there is no need of receipt or cash memo because every patient will be discharged with some dues so no receipt or cash memo will be provided. Such practice will keep the pockets of concerned full but public exchequer will cry.
Hon’ble CPIO may provide following information.
1-Please made available GO/CIRCULAR /ACT , 
WHICH allows transaction on a slip.
2-Whether Rs.10000.00 is taken on slip 
without providing any description of charges . 
Please made available provision of law allows 
such cryptic dealings.
3-Please made available information when more 
5000.00 deposited , then also transaction was made 
on slip .IT Mirzapur considers it legitimate. Please 
made available GO/CIRCULAR.
4-When rest of six thousand paid ,then slip was taken
 and patient was discharged and no receipt was given.
 Being top monitoring body ,please provide the 
provision of law which allows such cryptic practice.
5-Matter concerned with Commissioner of Income 
Tax , Officer name-GEET MALA MOHANANEY but 
department procrastinated by sending RTI 
Communique to various public authorities. Please 
explain the cause of procrastination.
5-It is submitted before the Hon’ble Sir that under point 1 ,it seems that 
CPIO has written character roll instead of providing sought information.
 The nursing home executing turn over of millions of rupees in 
one month ,performs its business on slip not cash memo or receipt. 
Thanks to staffs of income tax of government of India.
                                     
    This is humble request of your applicant to you Hon’ble Sir that It can never be justified to 
overlook  the rights of citizenry by delivering services in arbitrary manner by floating all set up norms. 
This is sheer mismanagement which is encouraging wrongdoers to reap benefit of loopholes in system 
and depriving poor citizens from right to justice. Therefore it is need of hour to take concrete steps 
in order to curb grown anarchy in the system. For this your applicant shall ever pray you Hon’ble Sir.
                                                                 Yours  sincerely
                                                     Yogi M. P. Singh Mobile number-7379105911
Mohalla-Surekapuram, Jabalpur Road District-Mirzapur , Uttar Pradesh ,India


Department of income tax is procrastinating instead of providing information.pdf
854K

2 comments on Lack of transparency in income tax department itself proved by its staffs which is root cause of slip culture

  1. Hon’ble CPIO may provide following information.
    1-Please made available GO/CIRCULAR /ACT ,
    WHICH allows transaction on a slip.
    2-Whether Rs.10000.00 is taken on slip
    without providing any description of charges .
    Please made available provision of law allows
    such cryptic dealings.
    3-Please made available information when more
    5000.00 deposited , then also transaction was made
    on slip .IT Mirzapur considers it legitimate. Please
    made available GO/CIRCULAR.

  2. 2. Information sought for is available in public domain.
    3. Information sought for does not pertain to this office.
    4. information sought for does not pertain to this office,
    The above information Is made available to you. If you are not satisfied with the above, you can appeal
    to the first appellate authority I.e. Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Range-III, Mirzapur within 30 days.
    Yours faithfully.
    Income Tax Officer
    Ward-3(2). Mkzapur.
    Whether the lady appellate officer is not apprised with the fact that made available information is incomplete information but she overlooked it as she wanted to conceal the wrongdoings of the office of which she is administrative head.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: