Fertilizer of more than 20 million rupees destroyed but government remained failed to fix accountability

Registration Number DOCMO/R/2020/60237
Name Yogi M P Singh
Date of Filing 30/06/2020
Status RTI REQUEST RECEIVED as on 30/06/2020
  Nodal Officer Details  
Telephone Number 9454413175
Email-ID shivprakashtiwari64992@gmail.com

Online RTI Request Form Details

Public Authority Details :-
* Public Authority Chief Minister office
Personal Details of RTI Applicant:-
Registration Number DOCMO/R/2020/60237
Date of Filing 30/06/2020
* Name Yogi M P Singh
Gender Male
* Address Mohalla Surekapuram , Jabalpur Road, Sangmohal post office
Pincode 231001
Country India
State Uttar Pradesh
Status Details not provided
Pincode Literate
Phone Number Details not provided
Mobile Number +91-7379105911
Email-ID yogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com
Request Details :-
Citizenship Indian
* Is the Applicant Below Poverty Line ? No
((Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters) )
* Description of Information Sought Grievance Status for registration number: GOVUP/E/2019/36610 Grievance Concerns To Name Of Complainant Yogi M. P. Singh Date of Receipt 10/11/2019 Report submitted by the Government of Uttar Pradesh as प्रकरण भारत सरकार रेलमंत्रालय से संबंध है। Public Information Officer Chief Minister Office, Government of Uttar Pradesh may provide the following information point-wise as follows.

1-Provide the notings regarding aforementioned grievance and minutes of proceedings.

2-Provide the name, designation and department of the staffs whoever processed the aforementioned grievance. 3- Provide the name, designation and department of the staffs whoever monitored the processing of the aforementioned grievance.

4-If the government of Uttar Pradesh had submitted an affidavit that if any loss occurred, the ministry of Railways will not be responsible as quite obvious with records attached to the grievance made available by Ministry of Railways and still available on Public grievance portal. Please provide the copy of the affidavit given to a concerned staff of the Ministry of Railways as aforementioned.

* Concerned PIO Nodal Officer
Supporting document ((only pdf upto 1 MB))

Grievance Status for registration number : GOVUP/E/2019/36610

Grievance Concerns To
Name Of Complainant
Yogi M. P. Singh
Date of Receipt
10/11/2019
Received By Ministry/Department
Uttar Pradesh
Grievance Description
Here it is quite obvious that fertilizers of more than 20 million rupees was destroyed because of the rainwater quite obvious from the reports published in the print and electronic media in the local daily but it is unfortunate that our public functionaries are overlooking this huge loss and supporting the mismanagement in the department concerned whether it is justified. According to Department of Railways, the concerned department is not claiming any loss occurred due to the negligence of the department of Railways and the department of the government of Uttar Pradesh but here quite obvious that there is a loss which occurred at a mass level quite obvious from the attached photographs. According to the Department of Railways, this could be avoided but it is unfortunate that concerned department of the government of Uttar Pradesh itself shown negligence in order to avoid the wastage of fertilizer otherwise fertilizer was directly loaded to the trucks from the wagon of the railway but not done so. Undoubtedly concerned staffs of the government are not serious about this loss because this detriment did not occur to them but actually occurred to the government and if someone other to whom this loss occurred those are the farmers of the area to whom useless ineffective fertilizer was sold by the department of agriculture of the Government of Uttar Pradesh. Here this question arises that why the department of the government of Uttar Pradesh gave the affidavit to the department of Railways that if any loss occurs then department itself would be liable it would not be the responsibility of the department of Railways. If the huge loss of fertilizer could be avoided by direct loading the packets of the fertilizers from the wagon of the railway to the trucks then why the concerned department of the government of Uttar Pradesh did not do so. Here core point is that the Government of Uttar Pradesh is avoiding to take the action against the accountable staff and not fixing the accountability of its staffs. More details are attached to the representation.
Grievance Document
Current Status
Case closed
Date of Action
21/12/2019
Remarks
प्रकरण भारत सरकार रेलमंत्रालय से संबंध है।
Rating
Poor
Rating Remarks
The matter is concerned with the deep rooted corruption and it is unfortunate that instead of taking action concern accountable public functionaries are procrastinating in the matter since more than free years. Whether it is justified on one side of screen, our Prime Minister Mr Narendra Modi Sir is claiming to provide good governance and corruption free government but his ministry is saying that the matter is concerned with state government and state government is saying that matter is concerned with the ministry of Railways. Whether government will solve the matter in this way even when the matter is concerned with complete mismanagement of the Ministry of Railway a as well as government of Uttar Pradesh. Here this question arises that why our governments are not interested to take action in order to overcome the corruption and Tyranny of the corrupt public functionaries which is ipso facto obvious. How the corruption will be overcome if Owl is seated at every branch. Thanks Sir.
Officer Concerns To
Officer Name
Shri Arun Kumar Dube
Officer Designation
Joint Secretary
Contact Address
Chief Minister Secretariat U.P. Secretariat, Lucknow
Email Address
sushil7769@gmail.com
Contact Number
0522 2226349
0 0 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Arun Pratap Singh
4 months ago

When it was feasible that fertiliser could be directly loaded to trucks instead platform and thus double handling could be avoided and safety fertiliser could be ensured but not done by the concerned staffs of the government of Uttar Pradesh. Which ascertain that defaulter is the staffs of the government of Uttar Pradesh. It is most surprising that fertiliser of 20 million destroyed and matter is intimated to apex court of India but no action was taken and accountability was not fixed is the reflection of insensitivity of the government.

Preeti Singh
4 months ago

Undoubtedly matter is sent to apex court of India and matter is serious as state exchequer suffered huge loss because of mismanagement and insensitivity of the concerned government functionaries but it unfortunate that apex court of India is only mute spectators of it. It is quite explicit that apex court is playing the role of Devbrat/ Bheesm Pitamah in the Mahabharat and Government is playing the role of Kaurav and poor people of this country is Pandvas. Apex court is watching the stripping of its daughter in-law.

Bhoomika Singh
4 months ago

Whether in the name of good governance government of Uttar Pradesh and the Government of India are providing complete mis management to the people of this country which is quite obvious from their cryptic working style which is obvious from the fact that on the one side of screen board of Railway is stating that there is no fault on the part of the staff of the ministry of Railways and they are providing the entire evidences but government of Uttar Pradesh is saying that matter is concerned with the ministry of Railways in order to avoid its skin which is mockery of the law of land. Such practices must be stopped.

Pratima Parihar
Pratima Parihar
4 months ago

रेलवे विभाग से उत्तर प्रदेश सरकार का कृषि विभाग खुद हलफनामा दिया है की किसी भी प्रकार के नुकसान का दावा नहीं करेगा अर्थात जान बूझ कर ख़तरा लिया गया , लेकिन यहाँ यह स्पष्ट है कि एक नुकसान हुआ है जो एक बड़े स्तर पर हुआ है संलग्न तस्वीरों से रेलवे विभाग के अनुसार, इससे बचा जा सकता था लेकिन यह दुर्भाग्यपूर्ण है कि उत्तर प्रदेश सरकार के संबंधित विभाग ने खाद की बर्बादी से बचने के लिए खुद ही लापरवाही दिखाई अन्यथा खाद सीधे रेलवे के वैगन से ट्रकों पर लादकर छति रोकी जा सकती थी |