Sameena Begum victim of arbitrary cancellation of ration card because of agents of public staff sold food grain on large scale

Sameena Begum submitted grievance before government of Uttar Pradesh against arbitrary cancellation of Ration card 

Grievance Status for registration number : GOVUP/E/2024/0014111

Grievance Concerns To

Name Of Complainant

Mahesh Pratap Singh alias Yogi M. P. Singh

Date of Receipt

26/02/2024

Received By Ministry/Department

Uttar Pradesh

Grievance Description

The matter concerns the working of the district supply officer, district Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh. The staff of the district supply officer took arbitrary action against the vulnerable applicant whose constitutional and human rights have been violated by the concerned public staff. It is most unfortunate that those indulged in corrupt activities by taking the blessings of the concerned accountable public staff were set free and people belonging to the weaker and downtrodden section were made scapegoats.

An application on behalf of Mrs Sameena Begam W/O Fatahu, Village-Mahuari Kala, Post Mahuari Kala, mohalla-Kewtan, Vindhyachal, District-Mirzapur, PIN Code-231307, mobile number-7084435815 to seek information under right to information act 2005 concerning arbitrary cancellation of the Ration card. 

The first page of the attached PDF document to the online rti application is the Ration card details of the aggrieved applicant Mrs Sameena Begam W/O Mr. Fatahu. The second page of the attached PDF document to the online rti application is the Aadhar card details of the aggrieved applicant Mrs Sameena Begam W/O Mr. Fatahu.

The third page of the attached PDF document to the online rti application is the Aadhar card details of the aggrieved applicant Guddu Ali S/O Nanhku S/O Mrs Sameena Begam W/O Mr. Fatahu. The fourth page of the attached PDF document to the online rti application is the revenue record details of the aggrieved applicant Mrs Sameena Begam W/O Mr. Fatahu.

Under article 51 A of the constitution of India the applicant is making following inquiry with the district supply officer, district-Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh regarding the arbitrary cancellation of the Ration card of the aggrieved applicant without providing proper opportunity to the aggrieved applicant.

1- Public information officer must provide the reason for the cancellation of the Russian card of the aggrieved applicant attached as the first page of the pdf document to the online rti application. 

2- Public information officer must provide the total price of the paddy and total price of the wheat sold by Guddu Ali S/O Nanhku 

3- Public information officer must provide the account details opened in the name of the son of the aggrieved applicant named Guddu Ali S/O Nanhku as well as financial transaction details made by the government into the account of my son.

4- Please provide the name and designation of the staff of the government on the basis of whose report cancellation of the Ration card was made by the office of district supply officer.

5- Whether any notice was issued by the office of district supply officer before cancellation of the Ration card of the aggrieved applicant to seek the explanation of the Ration card holder as an opportunity to prove her innocence as required under natural justice.

Please provide the copy of any such notice issued by the department before cancelling the Ration card of the aggrieved applicant.

Rule of Law defined by Dicey as the Supremacy of Law, Equality before Law. Rule of law according to Dicey means the absolute supremacy or predominance of regular law as opposed to the influence of arbitrary power or wide discretionary power.

Those who indulged in fraudulent activities during the purchase of the wheat and paddy were arbitrarily set free and those who became victim of those fraudulent elements were punished on the large scale by cancelling their Ration cards. Where is the social justice in this largest democracy in the world if there is an open gate of arbitrariness and tyranny?

Grievance Document

Current Status

Case closed   

Date of Action

13/03/2024

Remarks

प्रकरण में सम्बंधित से आख्या प्राप्त कर निस्तारण हेतु प्रेषित है आख्या संलग्न है उक्त प्रकरण की जॉच पूर्ति निरीक्षक द्वारा की गयी पूर्ति निरीक्षक की जॉच आख्या अनुसार आवेदक श्री महेश प्रताप द्वारा श्रीमती शबीना बेगम पत्नी फताहू के नाम से जारी राशनकार्ड निरस्त हो जाने के संबंध में शिकायत किया गया है उक्त के संबंध में अवगत कराना है कि एनआईसी से प्राप्त रिपोर्ट के अनुसार श्री फताहू द्वारा वित्तिय वर्ष 3 लाख से अधिक खाद्यान्न का विक्रय सरकारी क्रेन्द्र पर किया गया था जिससे एक्स क्लूजन का्रइटेरिया में आने के कारण राशनकार्ड निरस्त कर दिया गया था इस संबंध में मो0 8528613972 पर वार्ता कर अवगत करा दिया गया है श्री फताहू के बयान की छायाप्रति संलग्न है आख्या सेवा में सादर प्रेषित

Reply Document

Rating

1

Poor

Rating Remarks

The complaint has been made in connection with the said that as per the report received from NIC, more than 3 lakh food grains were sold by Shri Fatahu at the government centre in the financial year, due to which the ration card was cancelled.  In this regard, Conversation was made on the mobile number-8528613972. A photocopy of the statement of Mr. Fatahu is attached and sent respectfully in the service. There is little change in the story submitted by the concerned staff of the government of Uttar Pradesh on the Portal. Guddu Ali was misled by cheaters who committed the forgery in the matter on the large scale by colluding with the staff of the government and Guddu Ali is not a single victim sold more than Rs.3,00,000 food grain and Guddu did not support them, but Guddu Ali itself a victim of this cheating.  Whether it is justified in good governance of Yogi Adityanath to punish innocent and Gullible people who were cheated by fraudulent elements by collating with government staff.

Appeal Details

Appeal Number

Date of Receipt

Appeal Text

Current Status

Officer Concerns To

Officer Name

Shri Bhaskar Pandey (Joint Secretary)

Organisation name

Government of Uttar Pradesh

Contact Address

Chief Minister Secretariat , Room No. 321, U.P. Secretariat, Lucknow

Email Address

bhaskar.12214@gov.in

Contact Number

05222226350

To see the attached document to the grievance, please click on the link