State Human Rights Commission made blunder in deciding petition


 

To                                            

                                                                                   Honourable chairperson                                                                                       State Human Rights Commission of Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow

Subject-Executive Engineer EDD II Mirzapur Mr. Rajesh Kumar did not provide compensation to single farmers whose crops were burnt due to short-circuit during covid by taking recourse of the office memo i.e. Circular letter number-2828 dated -25 September 2021.Office memo date is 25 Sept 2021, crops burning date is 18 April 2021, report submitted by Tehsil is 19 June 2021, how can office memo of the Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation Limited applied on report?

COMPLAINT / CASE STATUS SHRC, Uttar Pradesh Case Details Diary No 816/IN/2023 Case / File No 736/24/55/2023 Victim Name DAYANAND SINGH Registration Date 09/03/2023Dismissed in Limini - NA 24/03/2023

Honourable commission passed the order as follows. Perused the complaint of Yogi M. P Singh. It appears that the complainant's son is an accused in the criminal case. He alleges that he has been falsely implicated in the aforesaid case. The issue regarding the innocence of the complainant cannot be decided by the Commission as the same falls within the domain of investigation. There is no allegation in the complaint that the case is not being investigated fairly. In view of the above I do not find any reason to interfere in the matter. The complaint is hereby rejected.

Short submissions are as follows.

1-Honourable commission did not take the perusal of the matter which is the cause of inconsistent order by the Honourable member. 

2-Undoubtedly it is a blunder but it is expected that the error is human. 

3-Member of U.P.H.R.C. must know that the matter concerns retrospection of the office memo dated  25 Sept 2021 of UPPCL by the Executive Engineer EDD II which deprived farmers of compensation.

4-Arbitrariness and tyranny of Executive Engineer EDD II Mirzapur Mr. Rajesh Kumar deprived a large number of farmers of compensation whose crops were burnt due to short-circuit during covid 19 period before Circular letter number-2828 dated -25 September 2021. This office memo was retrospectively applied in the cryptic manner instead of subsequent application. 

5-Here the matter concerns the circular letter number 2828 dated 25th September 2021 is an office memo of the Uttar Pradesh Power corporation limited. The crop of the Dayanand Singh son of Shobhnath Singh was burnt on 18th April 2021 due to short circuit. The report submitted by the concerned lekhpal on 15th June 2021 which was forwarded by the Kanungo and 19th June 2021. Here it is quite obvious that the circular issued by the Uttar Pradesh Power corporation limited is of later date and there is too much time interval. How can Executive Engineer Electricity Distribution division second mister Rajesh Kumar can do the retrospection by applying office memo of later date? The office memo issued by the Uttar Pradesh Power corporation limited must be applied in matters which are happening subsequently.                 

Please connect this revision by reviving the aforementioned petition of the petitioner in the interest of justice. 

COMPLAINT / CASE STATUS

SHRC, Uttar Pradesh

Case Details 

Diary No 1489/IN/2023 Case / File No 1341/24/55/2023

Victim Name DAYANAND SINGH Registration Date 18/04/2023

Action List (Click on Action given in blue color to view details)

No action taken yet

Expand All Action List

Complaint

Diary No 1489/IN/2023 Section M-2

Language ENGLISH Mode BY INTERNET

Received Date 18/04/2023 Complaint Date 18/04/2023

Victim

Victim Name DAYANAND SINGH Gender Male

Religion Hindu Cast General

Address VILLAGE AND POST NIBI GAHARWAR, ARJUNPUR FEDER

District MIRZAPUR State UTTAR PRADESH 

Complainant

Name YOGI M P SINGH

Address SUREKAPURAM COLONY , SHRI LAXMI NARAYAN BAIKUNTH MAHADEV MANDIR

District MIRZAPUR State UTTAR PRADESH ( 231001 )

Incident

Incident Place NIBI GAHARWAR MIRZAPUR Incident Date 07/11/2022

Incident Category ATROCITIES BY CUSTOM/EXCISE/ENFORCEMENT/FOREST/INCOME-TAX Deptt., etc.OF CENTRAL/STATE Govts.

Incident District MIRZAPUR Incident State UTTAR PRADESH

Incident Details


Comments