Enter Registration Number BKOIN/A/E/22/00125
Name Yogi M P Singh
Received Date 08/05/2022
Public Authority Bank of India
Status APPEAL DISPOSED OF
Date of action 07/06/2022
Reply :- Sir,
With due respect firstly we would like to draw your kind attention towards the provisions of Section 19(1) of the RTI ACT, 2005 which states that if you are aggrieved with the decision of CPIO then you may proceed to prefer an Appeal within 30 days of receiving the decision/reply but you have preferred appeal after expiry of 30 days i.e. after 53 days without providing any sufficient cause which would have prevented you from filing Appeal within prescribed timeframe which is in itself a sufficient ground to reject your first appeal.
But it the interest of justice we are entertaining your Appeal with observation as provided below:-
As per Section 4(1)(b)(x)- The monthly remuneration received by each of its officers and employees, including the system of compensation as provided in its regulations. The pay scales of employees of the Bank are fixed by IBA in consultation with Government of India, Ministry of Finance, New Delhi, which is provided on the official site on bankofindia which can be accessed by you through the following link:- https://www.bankofindia.co.in/rtiorg1 .
Moreover we would also like to draw your kind attention towards the decision of the Commission in the matter of- K. Lall vs. M.K. Bagri in which they held that- “once a certain information is placed in the public domain accessible to the citizens either freely, or on payment of a predetermined price, that information cannot be said to be 'held' or 'under the control of' the public authority and, thus would cease to be an information accessible under the RTI Act."
Secondly it has been observed that you are in the habit of preferring repetitive RTI’s followed by compulsorily preferring First appeal. By the time we dispose of your RTI Application we receive you first Appeal and as we dispose off your first Appeal we got another RTI from your end.
From the above findings we would like to draw you kind attention towards the decision of the CIC in the matter of- Mr. Ramesh Chand Jain Vs. DTC which is also known as a case of misuse of RTI, it was held by the commission that:-
i)There is No scope for repeating under RTI Act
ii)Citizen has no Right to Repeat
iii)Repetition shall be ground of refusal
iv)Appeals can be rejected on this Ground
As even a single repetition of RTI application would demand the valuable time of the public authority, first appellate authority and if it also reaches second appeal, that of the Commission, which time could have been spent to hear another appeal or answer another application or perform other public duty.
Thirdly, this is your 4th Appeal in continuity of your 4th RTI Request which means we have replied total 8 RTI Requests so far. Not this much we have also found that along with RTI requests you have also lodged various complaints on various portals too.
Fourthly, We would like to draw you kind attention towards the decision of the CIC in the matter of- Radha Raman Tripathy Vs CPIO (Central Information Commission) whereby it was provided that- “As much as a CPIO has a statutory responsibility of complying with the provisions of the RTI Act, it is also expected of the RTI applicant/s to not undermine the spirit of the RTI Act by clogging the system with a barrage of RTI applications, merely claiming that these are aimed at combatting corruption.
Lastly we would like to appraise you that RTI Act is made for seeking informations, if you have any grievance or complaints there are various ways to seek for the redressal of the same. RTI Act is not made to provide redessal of the grievances.
First Appellate Authority Details :- VARANASI - BHARAT SINGH FONIA
Phone: 0542-2518485
Varanasi[dot]Legal[at]bankofindia[dot]co[dot]in
Nodal Officer Details :-
Telephone Number 2266684566
Email Id ho[dot]rticell[at]bankofindia[dot]co[dot]in
Online RTI Appeal Form Details
RTI Appeal Details :-
RTI Appeal Registration number BKOIN/A/E/22/00125
Public Authority Bank of India
Personal Details of Appellant:-
Request Registration Number BKOIN/R/E/22/00146
Request Registration Date 11/02/2022
Name Yogi M P Singh
Gender Male
Address Mohalla Surekapuram , Jabalpur Road District Mirzapur, Sangmohal post office
Country India
State Uttar Pradesh
Status Urban
Educational Status Literate
Above Graduate
Phone Number +91-7379105911
Mobile Number +91-7379105911
Email-ID myogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com
Appeal Details :-
Citizenship Indian
Is the Requester Below Poverty Line ? No
Ground For Appeal Refused access to Information Requested
CPIO of Public Authority approached VARANASI - TAPAN KUMAR MANDAL
CPIO's Order/Decision Number Details not provided
CPIO's Order/Decision Date
(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)
Prayer or Relief Sought
Section 4(1)(b) in The Right To Information Act, 2005(b) publish within one hundred and twenty days from the enactment of this Act,(x) the monthly remuneration received by each of its officers and employees, including the system of compensation as provided in its regulations;
This implies that whatever information sought by information seeker must be disclosed by public authority voluntarily but you did not provide even after payment of requisite fee. The information sought concerns wide public interest and not personal information. You know well why you are running away from providing information.
Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB) Supporting document not provided
Enter Registration Number BKOIN/R/E/22/00146
Name Yogi M P Singh
Received Date 11/02/2022
Public Authority Bank of India
Status REQUEST DISPOSED OF
Date of action 16/03/2022
Reply :- We have considered your Application under various provisions of RTI Act, 2005. Please find attached point-wise reply of the information sought by you as hereunder:-
1-Reply- We wish to inform you that information which relates to personal information disclosure of which has no relationship with to any public activity or interest is exempted from disclosure under sec 8(1)(j) of RTI Act, 2005. So, we are unable to provide the same.
2- Reply- We wish to inform you that information which relates to personal information disclosure of which has no relationship with to any public activity or interest is exempted from disclosure under sec 8(1)(j) of RTI Act, 2005. So, we are unable to provide the same.
3-Reply- Strike/Period of Strike is not reckoned as service by the Sanctioning Authority as per the Banks policy therefore Deduction of salary of employees due to strike is based on the Principle of - NO WORK NO PAY Policy due to which Salary of each participating employee was deducted as no service on that day.
CPIO Details :- VARANASI - TAPAN KUMAR MANDAL
Phone: 0542-2518478
Varanasi[dot]GOD[at]bankofindia[dot]co[dot]in
First Appellate Authority Details :- VARANASI - BHARAT SINGH FONIA
Phone: 0542-2518485
Varanasi[dot]Legal[at]bankofindia[dot]co[dot]in
Nodal Officer Details :-
Telephone Number 2266684566
Email Id ho[dot]rticell[at]bankofindia[dot]co[dot]in
Online RTI Request Form Details
RTI Request Details :-
RTI Request Registration number BKOIN/R/E/22/00146
Public Authority Bank of India
Personal Details of RTI Applicant:-
Name Yogi M P Singh
Gender Male
Address Mohalla Surekapuram , Jabalpur Road District Mirzapur, Sangmohal post office
Country India
State
Status Urban
Educational Status Literate
Above Graduate
Phone Number +91-7379105911
Mobile Number +91-7379105911
Email-ID myogimpsingh[at]gmail[dot]com
Request Details :-
Citizenship Indian
Is the Requester Below Poverty Line ? No
(Description of Information sought (upto 500 characters)
Description of Information Sought
Enter Registration Number BKOIN/A/E/22/00021 Name Yogi M P Singh Received Date 21/01/2022 Public Authority Bank of India, For more feedback vide attached document.
1-Provide name, designation and amount of salary paid in the month of November 2021 to each staff in the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India.
2-Provide name, designation and amount of salary paid in the month of December 2021 to each staff in the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India.
3-Provide circular/ direction issued by employer to deduct salary of 16 and 17th December of each striker.
Concerned CPIO VARANASI - TAPAN KUMAR MANDAL
Supporting document (only pdf upto 1 MB)
Enter Registration Number BKOIN/A/E/22/00021 Name Yogi M P Singh Received Date 21/01/2022 Public Authority Bank of India, For more feedback vide attached document.
ReplyDelete1-Provide name, designation and amount of salary paid in the month of November 2021 to each staff in the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India.
2-Provide name, designation and amount of salary paid in the month of December 2021 to each staff in the Mirzapur city Branch of Bank of India.
3-Provide circular/ direction issued by employer to deduct salary of 16 and 17th December of each striker.